BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Cook Gear > Bear Resistant Containers > BearVault BV200 > Brian Tannehill > Field Report

Field Report BearVault BV200

By Brian Tannehill

Personal Information Background Information Product Information Field Locations Field Reporting Questions Concerns Conclusion

Personal Information:

Age: 29
Gender: Male
Height: 5' 7" (1.7 m)
Weight: 175 lbs (79 kg)
Name: Brian Tannehill
Date: 8 Aug 2004
Email: bj(at)tannehillclan(dot)com
Location: Lompoc, California, USA

Backpacking Background:

I am fairly new to backpacking, but I have hunted/fished/camped all my life in East Texas, Colorado, and California. The majority of the hunting has been done from a well-established base camp, venturing out from there for the day. Because of the young kids I have (2, 8, 10), I mostly do weekend overnight camping trips, or day hikes Geocaching anywhere along the central coast of California. I am also an avid mountain biker. My two oldest kids are boys and are getting to the point where they can come out more hiking and camping with me. I am looking forward to this in the future. For now I live in the Central Coast area of California (Lompoc, Santa Maria area), and am surrounded by many different areas from beaches to mountain regions ranging up to 5,000 feet (1,500 m), with the temperatures averaging about 60 F (16 C) degrees year round.

Product Information:

Manufacturer: BearVault
Year of Manufacture: 2004
www.bearvault.com
Year of Manufacture: 2004
Mfg Weight: 2 lb 7 oz (1108 g)
My weight: 2 lb 6.75 oz (1098 g)
Dimensions:
12.5 inches (31.8 cm) tall
8.5 inches (21.6 cm) wide
MSRP: $79.95 US

Field Locations:

The locations of my test have been varied from the beaches located in Central California, (Lompoc, Santa Maria area) to the Los Padres National Forest just east of here ranging up to 5000 feet (1500 m). We are getting into summer now, so temperatures will be around 70 F (21 C) by the beaches to 80 - 90 F (26 C - 32 C) inland.

Field Reporting

It's just plastic!! Well let me tell you it is some of the hardest plastic around. I have abused, kicked, beaten, thrown, bounced, and done everything I could to this thing and it did not break. The lid never popped off, and it barely got scratched. There is a seam that runs where the two halves are joined. I thought that would have been a good failure point, but so far it hasn't been. I have concentrated my efforts on the seam, and it shows no sign of busting. This thing is solid!

The lid also makes a decent seal. The manufacturer makes no claim that this lid is smell proof or waterproof. I put some dog food inside and let my beagle sniff at it. She acted like there was nothing in it. I tested it in the rain, by putting a piece of paper inside, then throwing it out in the yard overnight during a monsoon. The BearVault landed on its side with the lid in a puddle in the yard. I thought for sure it would get water inside, but it did not. The piece of paper was dry when I pulled it out after 24 hours. I was expecting it to at least have some moisture on it. None! I also left it out back for the racoons and other varmits to mess with at night. No luck, I found it kicked all over the yard by them, but they could not get in.

The BearVault is like having a small pantry with you out in the woods. I planned all my meals for 7 days, and then packed them inside the BearVault, with plenty of room to spare. My meals consisted of individual packages of ramen noodles, individual packages of quaker instant oatmeal, pasta, packages of red beans and rice and numerous little nick nacks of food. Power bars, apple drink mix, soups, and other odd and end things. Of course I only stay out for one or two nights right now. So my normal food intake is very minimal, so I had to find something else to haul with the food. I decided to put everything I did not want to get wet inside there. Electronic things, matches, extra clothes etc. Things that would not do good getting wet. I still had lots of room left over. This thing has a lot of space in it. Finally to fill this thing up, I took everything that was shoved in every little pocket of my pack, with all the food, and extra clothes, and things that can't get wet, and was just barely able to fill it up. It turned into a catch-all for all my little odds and ends I carry which is nice because now I don't have to go looking for them. On the down side though, it opened up about 3 pockets so I could add more stuff and have a heavier pack. Currently I am carrying a large lighter, a candlelantern, my cooking pot, alcohol stove, regular MSR Dragonfly stove and food for two nights out in the woods.

Most recently I took the BV200 car camping with the kids out in bear country, I mean the Los Padres National Forest. I also took an ice chest to store some cold food products in. My dilema now was how to store the cold products over night in the BV200? I got lucky and the bear container fit inside my cooler. I placed all the cold items in the bottom of the the canister, and then stuffed it down into the ice. This seemed to work as nothing spoiled.

The BV200 also works great for yellow jackets. I started cooking hamburgers that night and attracted every yellow jacket in Southern California. I did not know meat would attract them like it does. Usually they just followed about 30 seconds behind me whereever I moved the cooked burgers to, till I remembered I had the BV200. Once I put the meat in there, they never found it, and they flew around it and everything else out there.

This thing also works great as a footstool or a seat depending on where you are. I like to use it as a seat, especially when it is strapped to the outside of my pack because that is the easiest configuration to get to. When I stop I usually have to get in the canister for something, so I unstrap it, get what I need out, and then sit on it. There is a blurb on top of the lid about closing it fully before sitting on it.

One of the downfalls about this container is its size. It is almost too big to carry unless you are going out for an extended hike. Hence its 7 day capacity. A big pack is also required for this container. I have used it a few times in my medium ALICE pack and the BearVault will not fit in it with all my other stuff. Since then I have moved to a bigger older external framed hillary II, and the BV200 fits really nice. This model of the BearVault is designed for a 7 day outing. I would like to see one for a 2-3 day outing, maybe something about half the size.

I have used the BearVault BV200 with four different backpacks. The first pack I put it in was my trusty ALICE pack. This pack is about 2400 cubic inches. I have a medium ALICE and the BV200 fit well standing up inside the pack. I could pack some other gear in there with it, such as a change of clothes, and my small one man Eureka Gossamer tent inside but that was about it. This configuration left out my sleeping bag and pad though. I also tried turning the BV200 on its side and packing it in my ALICE pack. This worked but it made for a really tight fit of the BV200. This option added more room inside the pack, but I had a really hard time getting the BV200 out. I then tried strapping the BV200 to the outside of my ALICE but this did not work well. The ALICE has two cinch straps over the outside and they were not long enough to accommodate the BV200 and keep it in place.

ALICE
Not a whole lot of room left over.

The second pack I used it on was my LL Bean fly fishing pack. The LL Bean pack is a bit bigger than the ALICE at 2900 cubic inches. The BV200 fit fine standing up inside the pack. I was also able to pack both tent and BV200 into this pack, but that was really about it. I still needed some clothes, sleeping bag and a pad. I then turned the BV200 on its side and laid it in the pack. Length-wise it fit from side to side great, wasnt hard to pull out, and rode ok. I could also pack my tent, and my sleeping bag. What about my clothes? I could not get them in there. The other problem with this configuration is the BearVault sometimes rubs if I dont pack it right. I have to make sure I have great padding between me and the BearVault. Did I mention it is rock hard?

LL Bean

The third pack I used this with, and one of the best fits in an internal frame pack so far was my since destroyed North Face. This is an old panel loading blue and yellow NF with two main compartments on top and bottom. The bottom compartment has a zippered divider that was designed to hold a sleeping bag but instead worked great for the BearVault. I could lay the BV200 down inside the sleeping bag compartment, and add a few more odd and end small things like gloves or a small fleece jacket in with it. With the extra padding of the hip belt, I didn't feel the can rubbing me anywhere. I really liked having the BV200 in this configuration. Everything fit nicely into the pack. I could also add my tent and sleeping bag in the top half, strap my bed roll to the outside, and actually have a change of clothes in the pack with me. I'm not sure of the cubic inches of this pack, because I bought it used from someone years ago. My guess would be around 4000 + cubic inches.

North Face pack
The BearVault fits nicely in the sleeping bag compartment

The fourth pack I am now using is a very old Hillary II yellow external framed pack. The BearVault fits well in the top compartment, but I like it attached to the outside bottom of my frame. First its usually the heaviest thing in my pack so it can stay down low. Second I can have easy access to all my stuff. Third, sometimes when I stop I just sit with pack and everything on, the can helps support me when it is on the bottom. I dont really use the molded strap guides either. I think they are molded too wide, and I have not had any problems with movement from the small straps I am using. The lid is a bit harder to screw on when closing it while still strapped tightly to the frame. I have to loosen the strap by the lid to get it on.

Hillary 2
BV200 in the top of the pack.

side view
Side view of the BV200 strapped to outside of the frame.

straps
View of the straps

Some of my questions and concerns:

Another plus of having the BV200 strapped to the outside is it does not rub me. My LL Bean pack is a bit thin in the back pad, and the BV200 will rub the small of my back. Like I mentioned before I think the molded strap guides are a bit too far off center, especially the one towards the rounded bottom. The lid is still a bit tough to open especially if it is full and my hands are wet. I read something about getting some lubricant for it, which I will try and get from the web page. Some other questions to answer:
How will different straps work on the BV200? Will they slip? What happens if the lid is not fully closed before I sit on it? Will it break the threads?

Conclusion:

Overall this BearVault BV200 is rock solid. I really do not see any critter nor black bear getting into this thing. I certainly hope I don't find out.
Some of the better points of this container are:
Can be used for mutliple purposes. I.E. seat, storage for water sensitive gear
Catch all to keep things centrally located.
Is rock solid

Some of the downfalls: For me it's just too big. I don't see myself getting out for 7 days by myself. I do have another trip planned for two people over 3 days so I will see how it works for that. For myself though I would like to see a smaller 3-4 day version.

Brian

Read more reviews of
BearVault gear
Read more gear reviews by Brian Tannehill

Reviews > Cook Gear > Bear Resistant Containers > BearVault BV200 > Brian Tannehill > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson