| |
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
|
Long Term Report: Flatworld
(Orikaso) Fold Flat Solo Set
2 December 2006
About Wayne Merry,
the tester:
Age: 33
Gender: Male
Height: 1.8 m (5' 10")
Weight: 90 kg (200 lb)
Email address: wayne underscore merry at yahoo dot com dot au
City, State, Country: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Backpacking Background: I started backpacking about five
years ago, although I did day walks in childhood. I hike in various
terrains from moderate/hard track walks to some off track (including
river walks). I generally like the temperature to stay above freezing,
and have not camped above the snow line during winter. I enjoy going on
multi day walks up to about a week as well as day walks. I carry a
moderate weight pack to enjoy a few creature comforts at camp. I use a
tent for shelter. I would
normally do at least 2 overnight or multi-day walks every three months,
in addition to a number of 20 km (12 mile) or so day walks.
|
Testing Locations:
I have tested the Solo Set on the following walks in addition to
those reported on the Field Test Report. Walks are
multi-day unless otherwise noted:
- Croajingolong National Park - a remote coastal area in
eastern Victoria. Elevations varied from 0 m to 100 m (330
ft). The walk was mostly on track + beach sections. Temperatures
ranged from 5 C (41 F) to 15 C (59 F), with moderate humidity. The last
day of the trip saw moderate rain in the morning (always tends to
happen during packing up tents!). Other times on the walk were fine.
- Mt Monda: - a decent 800m (2600 ft) climb up and down day
walk in hilly national park area with
forested areas. Elevations varied from 200 m (650 ft) to 1000
m (3200 ft). This day walk was on track in light rain. Temperatures
ranged from 5 C (41 F) to 10 C (50 F), with high humidity.
I had a few other day walks in fine conditions. Due to an unexpected
business trip to Hong Kong, I missed out on two planned weekend walks
and was unable to undertake overnight walks late in the test period due
to the impending arrival of our first son. |
Product Details:
- Manufacturer: Flatworld (UK) Ltd trading as Orikaso
- Web site: http://www.orikaso.com/
- Year of manufacture: 2006
- Place of manufacture: China
- MSRP: Not available
The Orikaso Solo Set is a cup, bowl and plate sold as a set that fold
flat when not in use.
Specifications and my initial impressions can be found at my initial
review here.
My Field Report can be found
here.
|
Item Long Term Performance:
I have used the Solo Set on my trips for all three meals. My meals were
similar to those reported in my Field Report, such as cooked oats for
breakfast, crackers for lunch, rehydrated dinners and hot drinks.
During my testing, I used a range of criteria, and these were my
results:
- How convenient is the flat pack? Does it really take up
3 mm with all three items? The flat pack is convenient, taking up
much less space than a decent sized mug and bowl. If I was using
conventional crockery, I would only take a mug and bowl, but the full
Solo Set takes up less room. I would say that the flat pack is 1 cm
(0.39 in) rather than 3 mm (0.12 in) thick for practical purposes.
- How easy is it to assemble each item? In particular the
cup looks a bit complicated. Initially I found it a little
complicated, however once I had used the Solo Set a few times, I
quickly got use to using it. If I use a conventional mug, it is ready
right away as it does not need unfolding, but it takes me only 15
seconds or so to prepare each of the items for use. This is the price
to pay for the benefit of flat packing.
- How strong is the assembled item? Could it easily come
unpacked with food, especially liquids inside? Looking at the bowl,
there are four folds. This looks the most vulnerable to this happening.
Are my suspicions to be confirmed, or does the pressure of liquids keep
the folds securely in place? The folds represent a secure
mechanism. At no time did I have even the slightest doubt that the
mechanisms would fail and I would end up with hot soup or drink in my
lap. The folds on the bowl and cup are quite large and seemed very
secure. The folds on the plate are smaller, but even they seemed to
hold together well. I did not specifically test putting soup on the
plate (the plate is like a shallow bowl) to test the strength of these
folds, as the plate does not appear to be designed for this use. The
manufacturers web site suggested that the cup could leak if overfilled,
but the only leak I could produce is liquid escaping over the top!
- Does the bottom of the plate or bowl sag excessively?
No.
- How does the material transmit heat? If I am holding a
bowl of hot soup, do my fingers get burnt? Heat does get
transmitted through the material, and as the material is fairly thin
(and therefore light), this can happen more quickly than conventional
crockery. That said, I never found this to be a practical problem. The
bowl can be held near its edges, while the handle on the cup tends to
remain reasonably cool. I never found myself uncomfortable using the
Solo Set with hot food.
- Is it easy to handle the bowl with two hands?. Does the
bowl threaten to fold in the middle when held with two hands? Does one
side sag when held with one hand? None of these were a problem
with the Solo Set.
- Do the sides sag if the bowl or plate are placed on a
solid surface? No.
- Does some of my soup get lost in the folds? Yes
some does, but it is a very small amount that can be accessed as the
bowl is disassembled.
- How easy are the three items to clean? Is water and a
wipe good enough? Is there any odor retention? All 3 items are
easy to clean once disassembled because they are then flat. A water and
wipe is good enough for me, and my cleaning standards are fairly high.
- Is the bowl or plate big enough for my generous end of
day serves, or do I have to leave some in the pot getting cold for a
second helping? Yes, my serving sizes are generous (even though
this adds to backpack weight), and yes the bowl and plate are big
enough for big servings.
- How resistant is the material from scratching from
knives and forks? Am I going to see hundreds of scratch marks after a
few months? I could not see any scratches after my 4 months of use.
- Does the polypropylene weaken with the constant folding
and unfolding from use? Do the folds become resistant over time? The
manufacturer claims that the opposite will occur. Even after 4
months I remain undecided about this, but I do admit that I believe the
manufacturer more now than I did at the start of the test. The folds
have not failed during the test, and do not look like failing any time
soon.
- Does the material change by being exposed to heat? Does
it crack, bubble, flake or any other unwanted effect occur? I have
not seen any of these effects.
- How does the Solo Set survive the usual rumble and
tumble of being in a pack? I am still using the retail packaging
to carry the Solo Set in order to avoid things getting caught on the
folds. This retail packaging is clearly not going to out-survive the
Solo Set, so I am going to have to stop doing this at some stage. My
feeling is that I have been too cautious about this, and the folds will
handle the pack quite happily. The retail packaging is starting to show
a number of small rips, caused by the rumble tumble of being in a pack.
As highlighted in my Field Report, the cup could be improved by having
a hole in the handle, which would allow holding of the bowl and cup
with one hand. This is very handy in a bush walking camp setting where
there may be no facilities such as a table or chairs provided. I often
eat standing up, and this means that one of the cup or bowl is left on
the ground, where it is vulnerable to being kicked over or dirt being
kicked into it.
Overall, I have been happy with the performance of the Solo Set so far.
It's not perfect, but it is quite good, and I will continue to use it.
|
Likes and Dislikes:
Things I like about the Flatworld (Orikaso) Solo Set:
- Flat packing certainly saves space in my pack.
- With practice, I can quickly assemble out in the field.
- Easy to clean.
Things I dislike about the Flatworld (Orikaso) Solo Set:
- The cup should be redesigned to allow fingers to pass
through the handle.
- The plastic edges (particularly on the cup) are a little
sharp.
|
Read more reviews of Flatworld gear
Read more gear reviews by Wayne Merry
|