BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Cook Gear > Cooking Accessories > Jetboil French Press > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Field Report

Jetboil French Press
Field Report
June 28, 2005

Contents:
     Tester Information
     Product Information
     Report

Tester Information

Name: Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Location: Los Altos, CA

Age/Sex: 27/Female

Height: 5'5" (1.65 m)

Weight: 125 lb (57 kg)

Email: rebecca@backpackgeartest.org

Website: http://www.calipidder.com

I began backpacking in the summer of 2000 after moving to California. Although I started off carrying everything but the kitchen sink, my style has shifted to lightweight gear and techniques, though I am known to carry a few luxury items.   First in my heart is summer backpacking, but I also enjoy snowshoeing, skiing, and snowcamping, as well as long dayhikes and peak climbing.  I spend time outside during weekends year-round in the deserts and mountains of California. My weekend hikes are often 'spur-of-the-moment', and usually occur in and around Yosemite National Park, Desolation Wilderness (near Lake Tahoe), and Sonora Pass in the Sierra Nevada mountains, as well as Lassen National Park and Mt. Shasta area in the Southern Cascades.

Product Information

Name: Jetboil French Press

Manufacturer: Jetboil

Manufacturer website: www.jetboil.com

Year of Manufacture: 2005

Listed Weight: 1.2 oz/34 gm

Measured weight: 2 oz/57 gm

MSRP: $19.95

 

Contents with french press
 
The Jetboil French Press is a companion piece to the Jetboil Personal Cooking System.  The French Press is sold separately and collapses down for stowing inside the PCS cup. 

Field Conditions
During the field testing period I had the opportunity to use the Jetboil French Press in three different and distinct field conditions, in addition to some use at home.
 
To get used to it, I first used the French Press in the comfort of my own home on my front porch, and of course, at home I had things available to me like a sink, garbage, and unlimited paper towels if things got messy.  The first venture out into the field was on a snowcamping overnight to Loch Leven Lakes on the northwest side of Lake Tahoe.  I especially like my coffee on cold snowy mornings!  In this case, it was actually a warm sunny morning, but there was still snow on the ground. 
 
The next venture into the field was on an overnight backpacking trip in Henry Coe State Park, where it was hot and sunny and grassy.  Due to all of the rain this winter the grass in this park was shoulder-high in places and made finding a campsite and place to cook a bit tricky.  And, even in the hot weather, I still enjoy my coffee!
 
The final field use was on a car camping trip at Lava Beds National Monument.  Car camping gave me such luxuries as unlimited paper towels (stashed in the trunk of the truck) and running water, not to mention the picnic table that gave me an even and steady surface to cook on.
 

Field Report
I learned a few things during the process of testing the Jetboil French Press.  These things are:
  • Coffee always tastes good when backpacking and camping, no matter how it turns out. (I'm a bit pickier when I'm at home and have all my coffee-making parephenalia and toys at hand).
  • The standard French Press method for making coffee is a bit messy and complicated for my tastes for making coffee in the backcountry.
  • But...there are tricks to make the French Press method less messy and complicated with the Jetboil French Press - yay!

As I mentioned in my Initial Report, I love a good cup of coffee.  My day can't begin until I've had that first sip of the wonderful brew, but in the backcountry I've relegated myself to tea for a morning caffeine kick.  Tea is just plain easier and lighter weight to carry in and out, as well as prepare.  But when I saw that Jetboil made a French Press accessory for the PCS I decided it was time to introduce quality coffee to my backcountry mornings.

The French Press is made of four parts.  The lid is interchangeable with the standard PCS lid, and considering that the remaining components of the French Press weigh less than an ounce and pack within the PCS it is perfect for the lightweight backpacker who is already carrying the PCS.  To carry the French Press in addition to the standard PCS it costs 0.75 ounces of weight - not bad!

The lid of the French Press differs from the standard lid in two ways.  First, it is a slightly rubberier and more flexible material.  Second, it has a hole in the center that is big enough for the shaft of the French Press to pass through.  The other pieces of the French Press are the filter, and the shaft which breaks down into two pieces for easy and convenient storage within the PCS. 

Disassebled    assembled

Making coffee with the French Press is simple.  I boil water in the Jetboil like normal.  When it boils, I add the coffee grounds and stir briefly.  I then assemble the French Press and insert it into the PCS.  I let the filter rest on top of the grounds while the coffee brews and snap on the lid with the plunger of the French Press sticking out of the top.  After approximately four minutes I press the plunger down to compress the grounds to the bottom of the PCS.  I can then pour my coffee into my mug, or drink it straight from the PCS (I prefer to use a seperate cup). 

I've had a problem with this standard method.  I use two other French Presses in my day-to-day life and neither of them have this problem.  I've had this problem when not paying attention as well as when being very careful.  The French Press is a bit 'wobbly', in that when the lid is snapped on to the PCS while the filter is sitting on top of the coffee there can be a bit of wobble in the shaft.  If the filter is not kept even it can dip into the grounds.  These grounds then find their way above the filter so that when it is pressed, these grounds don't get filtered out.  The first time I ended up with crunchy coffee I vowed to be more careful the next time.  The next time I was very careful and still ended up with some grounds in my coffee.  In fact, every single time I've used the filter this way grounds have made it through.  I don't have this problem with either of the other two French Presses I use.

There is another problem with this standard method, and that is the cleanup.  When the coffee is poured, and the filter removed, what is left is a pile of wet coffee grounds stuck in the bottom of the PCS.  Plus, the grounds are stuck all over the filter.  Cleaning this up in the backcountry, especially when water is limited, is not easy.  In the snow I dumped the grounds and then used some paper towels to wipe up the inside of the PCS.  I stuck the filter in the ziploc baggie I had carried the coffee grounds in and washed it when I got home - since it was just an overnight trip it was much easier to deal with it at home than on the trail.

All of this sounds so negative, but some clever Jetboil engineers gave one of the testers a piece of advice that I tried, and it greatly reduced the headaches described above.  Hurray!  I'll call this clever technique the Reverse French Press method.  This is how it works:

Boil the water as usual.  Once the water is boiled, press the French Press to the bottom of the PCS before adding the coffee grounds.  After the coffee grounds are added, let it soak for the standard period of time.  Then, gently pull the French Press upward and out of the PCS.  If it is pulled up gently and carefully it captures all of the grounds.  The coffee remains in the PCS without the ugly mess of grounds hanging out in the bottom.  All of the grounds are captured by the filter, making it only one thing that needs cleaning from the coffee grounds. 

I have had much more success using the reverse method with the Jetboil French Press than the regular method.  This Reverse method doesn't work with any of the other French Presses I use, but it works great with the Jetboil!  The coffee I have made this way has tasted better and hasn't had grounds in it.  The cleanup is much easier too!

In my Initial Report I was concerned about the durability of something as delicate as the fine filter used in the French Press.  Luckily this stores easily in the bottom of the PCS and isn't tossed randomly into my pack.  The PCS protects it when it is in my pack and storage, so I don't have this concern any more.

I am left with a dilemma at the end of this test.  I really do enjoy having fresh (Reverse) French Press made coffee in the morning.  The tradeoff is the somewhat messy cleanup, and there are some mornings where I'd just rather have a cup of tea or a single-serving low quality coffee brew bag and be done with it.  I think that in the future this will be more of a car-camping accessory, where I have ready access to water, paper towels, and garbage cans.  This elimitates the problem of packing the supplies in and the trash out and having to clean up the messy Jetboil in the backcountry before the next use.  The messy cleanup is just a result of the French Press way of making coffee and not a result of Jetboil's design, and it's a tradeoff that one must decide to make for quality coffee.
 
 

 

 



Read more reviews of Jetboil gear
Read more gear reviews by Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Reviews > Cook Gear > Cooking Accessories > Jetboil French Press > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson