![]() |
| Home | Guest - Not logged in | |||
|
» Register
» Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
» Contact
|
Reviews > Cook Gear > Stoves > Jetboil Personal Cooking System > Paul Schilke > Long Term ReportLong Term Report: Jetboil
Stove (Personal Cooking System)
10/04/2004
Personal Data:
Name: Paul Schilke
Age: 31
Sex: Male
Weight: 165 lbs (75 kg)
Location: Laramie, Wyoming USA
Email: schilkepaul at yahoo dot com
Product Information:
Manufacturer: Jetboil
Model: Personal Cooking System
Year of Manufacture: 2004
MSRP: $80
Weight
Listed: 14 ounces (397 grams)
Verified: 12.9 ounces (366 grams)
Fuel Canister, Full: 5.8 ounces (164 grams)
Cooking Cup Capacity:
Listed: 1 quart (1 liter)
Measured: 34 fl ounces (1 liter)
Dimensions of Pot with Sipper Lid and bottom cover
in place:
Height: 7 inches (17.8 centimeters)
Width: 4.5 inches (11.4
centimeters)
Features:
Sipper Lid Cooking Cup with Cozy and
Exhaust Vents / Heat Exchangers Bottom Plastic Cover (doubles as measuring cup)
Burner Base with igniter button, control valve and wind screen
How it works:
The Jetboil Personal Cooking System takes
the all-in-one package approach to cooking on the trail. Not counting the fuel
canister, the Jetboil PCS consists of 4 pieces: (1.) the Burner Base, which
includes the igniter, control valve and wind screen; (2.) 1 quart (1 liter)
Cooking Cup which includes an attached heat exchanger and vent area, and a
removable neoprene cozy with attached ballistic nylon handle; (3.) a plastic lid
which doubles as a Sipper Lid; and (4.) a plastic cover which serves as a
measuring cup, as a cover over the sipper hole during cooking and as a bottom
cover during storage and steeping. All pieces, including the recommended fuel
canister, fit inside the Cooking Cup or snaps onto the exterior for storage. The
Cooking Cup is where the Jetboil PCS differentiates itself from other canister
stoves.
The Cooking Cup serves as pot and cup. The
Sipper Lid is made of a heat resistant plastic; during initial testing, after
3.5 minutes, the lid stayed quite cool. The lid has 2 holes in it, one for
sipping drinks, the other serves as a breather hole. There is no closure door on
the Sipper Lid, during boiling I laid the bottom cover over the Sipper Hole. The
cup slides into the burner and rotates to lock on, a nice feature I've never
seen on any other cooking system. The point of attachment is 1.75 inches (4.5
centimeters) below the bottom of the cup's interior. The extra space provides
venting and room for the heat exchangers. Supposedly, the heat exchangers serve
to multiply the burner's efficiency by increasing the surface area exposed to
the burner's flame (the fact that the Cooking Cup attaches to the Burner Base
also acts as a multiplier.)
The Cooking Cup has 2 other innovative and
potentially useful features. A neoprene sleeve measuring .04 inch (1 millimeter)
encircles the Cooking Cup, Jetboil calls this sleeve a "cozy". In the hiking
world a cozy typically describes an insulating sleeve into which a hot pot is
placed after bringing the water and food to a boil. The idea is that the food
will continue to cook and less fuel is used per meal. The idea works for some
and for others it doesn't. The course of this test will test the cozy idea of
steeping food in hot water after the burned is turned off. The one problem with
using the Cooking Cup and Cozy to steep food is the exposed heat exchanger on
the bottom and Sipper Lid hole at the top. The solution to the latter could be
to simply cover the Sipper Lid holes with a sock, wash cloth or other sundry
item. The solution to the former could lie in the bottom Plastic Cover; replace
it after removing the cup from the stove and the heat exchanger fins are
covered.
At first glance, the Plastic Cover appears
to be made of material similar to the Sipper Lid. However a simple scratch test
shows it to be more brittle than the Sipper Lid; it is as heat resistant and
more durable, given that I cracked the sipper lid near the breather hole. The
Plastic Cover is also a measuring cup, clearly demarcated as 1/4 cup ( .06
liter), 1/2 cup ( .13 liter) , 3/4 cup ( .18 liter) and 1 cup ( .24 liter) It
does not provide metric conversions. The plastic is hard for me to remove with
one hand, requiring that I grip the Cooking Cup between my legs as I work the
cover off. I think that if the bottom plastic cover were made of the same
plastic as the Sipper Lid, it would flex and come off more easily.
A hand strap made of ballistic nylon is
sewn into the cozy. So far the handle is a very effective and lightweight
alternative to the handles used by other pots. I can hold the pot by the handle
or the cozy with great comfort. This is certainly true after simmering food 10
minutes.
Although the Cooking Cup can hold 34 fluid
ounces (1 liter), it is full to the brim at that point. Inside the pot is
scribed a max fill line at the 2 cup (.58 liter) point. While that demarcates
the safe fill line, they are ways to work around it. I enjoyed using it as
instructed. The Burner Base houses the cooking control valve. I believe that the
control valve provides a true simmer, a luxury I've not experienced with the
white gas or alcohol stoves I've owned in the past.
The burner base also provides a piezo
electric igniter allowing me to leave my lighter stored in a plastic bag for
emergency uses only. After turning the control valve on, a push of the igniter
button throws a spark to the right location for prompt flame creation.
Long Term Report:
In the field report I complained of problems burning
oatmeal and commented that I probably had fully discovered how to use the
simmer. I discovered quite accidentally how to use the simmer. Turn the gas
level down until you remove the "jet" noise but not all the way snug off and
you've got the simmer. This being my first experience with a simmer stove, I was
pleasantly surprised at how it worked.
While atop the rocky, treeless tundra of Medicine Bow
Peak, with the University of Wyoming Geography Club, I discovered the simmer
function in this manner. While others munched on granola bars, I busted out the
Jetboil and attached the burner to the canister. I filled the Cooking Cup with
water and attached it to the burner. The tall stance of the entire outfit
coupled with a narrow base made for an obviously unstable situation. That noted
I made an attempt to get the stove started. With the ability to use only one
hand I found that the control was hard to turn on at first. After I finally got
the knob to turn on, I found that the wind made it hard to light the Jetboil's
fire. I built a shield of the rocks and successfully balanced the tippy stove on
a less than even surface. After a couple of tries and redistribution of rocks, I
was able to get the fire lit. Within a couple of minutes the 12 ounces of water
(.35 liters) were boiling, without turning down the heat, I emptied the packets
of oil and spice into the cooking and proceeded to open the packet of Raman
noodles. The spices however, instantly caused the water to boil over. I
struggled with the control knob to turn down the fire, instead I turned it up.
Finally I was able to turn off the stove, or so I thought. When I went to
relight the stove, I found that it fired right back up to the "jet" noise level,
as I turned up the gas, without having to hit the piezo button. I left the stove
burning at the lower level for what would be the remaining 3 minutes of cook
time.
The other discovery I made about the stove took place on
the Manistee River Trail. Before heading out on the hike, I had reviewed the
instruction. They said to be sure not to over tighten the canister. Well of
course I was made sure to follow that instruction. When using the stove that
weekend I found that boil times had increased to 10 minutes, a far cry from the
3 to 4 minute boil times I had experienced in the past. The problem in this
case turned out that the canister was not sqrewed on as tightly as it
should. Screwing the canister back on tightly was sufficient to get the
stove back up to par.
One morning when the temperature was below freezing and I went to fire up
the stove, it acted like it didn't want to start. After a couple of tries it
finally caught, I'm not sure if the starter was damp or the gas was too cold.
With a partially full, Jetboil canister of fuel, boil times at 7,000
ft (2100 m) were over 4 minutes.
Field Conditions:
The Jetboil PCS performed well on two hiking expeditions
in Michigan and several expeditions in Wyoming. Medicine Bow Peak, at 12,000 ft
(3700 m) was the highest altitude at which the Jetboil was used. The Jetboil was
also used on a weekend trip to Yankee Springs State Park in Southwestern
Michigan and the Manistee River Trail in Western Michigan. The Jetboil was used
at other location in Michigan and in Wyoming's Medicine Bow National Forest. The
Jetboil was used in high winds at temperatures ranging from 32° F (0° C) to 65°
F (36° C).
Summary:
This great product, convenient and reliable so far.
Storing the stove as one unit is not always workable. I don't always wash dishes
on the trail. In reality I'll toss the unwashed stove back into my pack without
having replaced the fuel canister and burner inside. I also think the plastic
bottom cover could be made of more flexible plastic similar to the Sipper Lid
(but given my experience with the lid cracking perhaps I need to rethink this
statement.) My main complaint with the bottom cover is that it is hard to
remove. Rolling boil time tested out to be over 4 minutes (cold tap water,
2 cups (.47 liters), half empty Jetboil fuel canister.)
Things I like
Things I don't like
Backpacking Background:
In 2002, I hiked 92% of the Appalachian Trail, taking
7.5 months to do so. In September of 2003, I walked 350 miles (564 km) across
Michigan's Upper Peninsula on the North Country Trail. Before those experiences,
I was very active outdoors: canoeing through Canyonlands National Park, biking,
day hiking, cross country skiing and doing other things.
Since 2002, I've been backpacking regularly. In the past
I've slept under tarps, in shelters and in tents. I've used both Bearicades,
and, the bear cans that weigh a pound more. I've cooked on alcohol stoves, white
gas stoves, and canister stoves. I always keep an eye to cutting down pack
weight because ounces (g) make pounds (kg) and pounds (kg) make tons (?).
Read more reviews of Jetboil gear Read more gear reviews by Paul Schilke Reviews > Cook Gear > Stoves > Jetboil Personal Cooking System > Paul Schilke > Long Term Report | |||