BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Cook Gear > Stoves > WildWood 1 Stove > Mike Lipay > Initial Report

Initial Report - Makaira WildWood I Backpacking Stove

by Mike Lipay - August 28, 2006

Personal Information
Name Mike Lipay
Age 51
Gender Male
Height 5 ft 8 in / 173 cm
Weight 185 lbs / 83.9 kg
Email hiking AT westernpa DOT us
City, StatePlum, Pennsylvania
Background I've been hiking and backpacking since the '60s. I enjoy hiking solo, with my kids, or with one of the two hiking groups to which I belong. I have taught LNT skills, wilderness survival, and outdoor first-aid. I am no ultra-light backpacker (my pack typically weighs 29-40 lb (13-18 kg) loaded), although I am always looking for ways to cut down on the weight. I'm a low-techie, preferring a hiking staff to trekking poles, compass to GPS, fire to fuel; but I am open to new products when there is a distinct advantage over more traditional "technology".



Description
Date Arrived August 21, 2006 Stove
Model WildWood I
Manufacturer Makaira Metalworks
Year of Mfgr 2006
Website www.MakairaMetal.com
MSRP $30.00 USD
Warranty The WildWood I will offer many years of reliable use. We are so sure of this that if any part of the stove fails, just return it and we will repair or replace it for free.
Mfgr. Specs Weight: 17 oz (482 g)
Height: 4 3/4 in (12 cm)
Diameter: 5 1/2 in (14 cm)
Personal measurements Weight: 17 oz (480 g)
Height: 4 3/4 in (12 cm)
Diameter: 5 3/8 in (14 cm)



First Impression Pieces Upon opening the package (the WildWood I arrived in a bubble wrap envelope) the first thing that impressed me was the heft of the stove, it had a good, solid feel to it. It was also a bit heavier than I expected, after all a backpacking stove is suppose to be light-weight, right? The WildWood I isn't light, at a little over a pound (453 g) it tips the scales on what I expect for backpacking. For those use to toting fuel bottles the weight would still be below what a typical stove and fuel setup would weigh; being used to a wood burning stove though, this is heavier than what I usually carry.

The second thing that impressed me was how compact the WildWood I was, with a diameter of 5 in (12.7 cm) and a height of barely 3/8 in (10 cm) in height, this is definately the smallest stove I've ever carried.

Quality of construction was very favorable, while the signs of cutting can be seen along the edges, there are no sharp surfaces or burrs protruding - signs of a high quality manufacturing process. Where the manufacturing did fall short though was on the carry sack included, semi-attached threads were at every seam inside the sack, and the hooks used to assemble the WildWood I snag on the threads every time I have removed the stove. It took only a few seconds to cut the loose thread, but it still annoyed me at having to do so.

The final item that caught my attention was how the pieces were designed to fit together: each side piece has two hooks on each side which will interlock into the hooks on the mating piece (see photo). Quite clever.

Assembly Having assembled quite a few of the houses for my train set I was familiar with how the WildWood I stove goes together (a quick look shows the same type of hook-into-hook features).

Basically, I started off holding one of the sides with its hooks pointing up, the two adjoining pieces were held so that their hooks pointed down; assembly was carried off by sliding the hooks of one side into the notches of the mating side. This continued around the circle until everything but the door was in place.

First Assembly

At this point the base of the stove is slid inside the assembly so that the tabs on the base fit into the notches of the sides. One point of note, the front of the base has no tab, and the door has no notch, once the base is in place the door simply slides down to connect the two open sides forming the stove (see photos).

Once together the WildWood I can be picked up by holding any two sides (except the door), the interlocking features keep the WildWood I from falling apart. Again, a very clever way to make the stove.

Mid Assembly
Usage Instructions are simple enough: start building a fire inside the stove with tinder, kindling, and small burnable items (wood, pine cones, etc.) found around the campsite. Ignite the tinder then, once the fire has caught, start cooking. Simple enough. As the fire burns down additional fuel can be added through the opening in the door. What is required to carry this off are a few additional items, which might not be packed under normal conditions: matches (or lighter), and something to cut the fuel into small enough pieces; my choice for these two items were a Blast Match (flint and steel product) and a set of plastic pruning sheers.
Test Plan Initially I plan on testing the WildWood I stove in my backyard -- my personal rule of thumb is to never take a new piece of equipment on a trek without first testing it near home, and a stove is no exception. I typically cook with a wok (one-person size) as it fits my type of cooking best -- I rarely do freeze-dried packages, preferring to cook with foil-packaged foods (tuna, chicken, Zatarains, rice dishes), or with fresh ingredients. So boiling water is a minor part of my typical fare, but will be part of my testing since I do enjoy a cup of tea with my meals.

I plan on performing a number of tests to determine how well and how quickly the WildWood I can make typical meals; also to be determined is the amount of fuel needed to carry out these tasks. Currently I will pick up burnable objects as I walk through the woods, targeting at a sandwich-size plastic bag filled with objects like pine cones, dry pine needles, nuts (and husks), etc. I find that this is what I typically need for 20-30 minutes of burn on my current wood stove.

For inclement weather I always bring along some wax-coated fire starters, this will be no exception. I find that this type of fire started is capable of burning long enough to get fuel the size the WildWood I uses dry enough to start burning. Hopefully they won't be needed.

Concerns While the WildWood I does assemble flat enough to put a pot on top, I still wonder how it will fare on an uneven surface, since flat areas are not common in the mountains of Pennsylvania.

I'm still wondering if the stove will cool down quick enough on a lunch break to be ready to store back in my pack when I'm ready to take off again. The thickness of the steel, and the size of the stove, make me think it might not cool down quick enough.

Makaira suggests clearing the area under the stove before starting the fire, as burnable pieces can fall through the openings. Since the areas I visit are biologically active I have a concern that use of this stove might kill the organics in the soil, I will monitor how hot it gets underneath. If sufficient heat is generated to kill the biologics within the top few inches then I might have to reconsider where I do my cooking (LNT and all that).

My next concern is how efficiently the WildWood I consumes the fuel, currently I am used to having only ashes remaining after a typical cooking session. Will I have to deal with larger pieces that need properly extinguished before leaving?

Finally, how will the rangers in my area view this stove? My current stove has a totally enclosed combustion chamber, while the WildWood I is much more open. Will the WildWood I be allowed when the risk of fire is high? During these times the rangers prohibit open fires, will I be allowed to use the WildWood I when restrictions are in place?

Locations The WildWood I will be tested on several trips within the Allegheny Mountains of Southwestern Pa., and in the Allegheny National Forest, if permitted (see final concern above). Elevations range from 800 ft (240 m) to 2500 ft (760 m) above sea-level. The next 4 months (Sept. thru Dec.) will see a range of temperatures from mid-80's to mid-40's, and precipitiation changing from rain to snow. Fuel sources will vary from dry to wet to snow-encrusted. All of these conditions should give the WildWood I quite a workout.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank both Makaira Metalworks and BackpackGearTest for the chance to test the Wildwood I stove.



Read more reviews of Makaira Metalworks gear
Read more gear reviews by Mike Lipay

Reviews > Cook Gear > Stoves > WildWood 1 Stove > Mike Lipay > Initial Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson