BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Do It Yourself > Repair Kits > McNett Tenacious Tape > Tim Coughlin > Field Report

McNett Corporation

Tenacious
Sealing and Repair
Tape

Field Report

16 July 2006

pix1

       

Tester Biography

Product Information

Field Report

Summary 

 

 

 

 

 

This Field Report is the final report of a series of two reports written over a four-month test period.  Please refer to the Initial Report for more information.

 

Tester Biographical Information

Name: Tim Coughlin
Gender: Male
Height: 5 ft 11 in (1.8 m)
Weight: 190 lb (86 kg)
Age: 44
Email: TCoug7<at>yahoo<dot>com
Test Location: Western New York, Northern Pennsylvania, Adirondack Mountains
State: New York
Country: United States

Backpacking Background:

I have been an active backpacker for 30 years, with experience hiking in many parts of the continental United States and Canada. Most of my time is spent in the Northeast, especially the Adirondack region of New York State. I practice lightweight and ultralight philosophies when backpacking. I’m a seasoned veteran to three-season backpacking, and have been expanding my experience outdoors to include winter backpacking. I am an avid four-season dayhiker. 

Product Information

Name: Tenacious Sealing and Repair Tape
Manufacturer: McNett Corporation
Web Site:

www.mcnett.com

Date of Manufacture: Unknown

Size Listed:

Roll of Tape 3 x 20 in (7.5 x 50 cm)

Size Measured:

Roll of Tape 3.125 x 19.75 in (8 x 50 cm)
Storage Tube 3.375 long x 1.125 diameter (8.5 x 3 cm)

Measured Weight:

Tape                     0.5 oz (14 g)
Storage Tube      0.4 oz (11 g)

Full roll in Tube    0.9 oz (25.5 g)

Color: Tape is clear; storage tube translucent blue
Warranty:

None Listed

Price: Not Available
Specifications:
  • Removable
  • Leaves no Residue
  • Better Than Duct Tape
  • Clear Matte Finish
  • Ideal for Tents, Rain Flys, Sleeping Bags, Backpacks, Jackets, Rain Gear, Gaiters, Waders, Fishing Gear, Paddling Gear & More

 

Other:

Adhesive Option: If more permanent repairs are desired, Tenacious Tape can be used with Seam Grip® or Aquaseal® Urethane Adhesives.  If used in this manner, follow adhesive application instructions and overlap the adhesive with Tenacious Tape by at least 1 inch (25mm).  Once adhesive is fully cured, the tape may be removed if desired.

Storage and Care: Store unused portion of tape in sealed plastic bag.  Tenacious Tape is washable. Do not dry clean.

What they Say: For Instant Repairs!  Tenacious Brand repair tape is ideal for fast in-field repairs on tents, tarps, rain gear, fishing gear and more.  Our super aggressive adhesive sticks to almost any surface and can be used for a variety of flexible, long lasting repairs.  Our non-gloss finish is almost invisible, eliminating the need to match colors on fabrics and other materials.  Instantly seals leaking seams, tears and pinholes, stops rips from spreading and acts as an abrasion-resistant shield on high-wear areas.  Can be used in conjunction with McNett Urethane Adhesives for ultra strong repairs. - From the McNett Website

Field Report

Field Testing Information:

Testing of the Tenacious Tape has included five 3-day treks with the Boy Scouts, numerous dayhikes, as well as everyday for some gear.  , The weekend treks all included hiking with my sons' Boy Scout Troop.  The treks included: a weekend hiking the Finger Lakes Trail in April around Letchworth State Park in central New York, two weekends in April and May, at our local Council camp and two weekends in June and July spent hiking in the Allegheny National Forest.  The local camp is located in southern New York.  The terrain along the FLT (Finger Lakes Trail) is predominantly flat and covered in deciduous hardwood forests; southern New York has gently rolling hills; with Allegheny Forest in the heart of the Allegheny Mountains.  The National Forest is about 1.5 hours south of here.  It has a number of circuit hikes as well as end-to-end hiking.  The North Country Trail runs from one end of the Forest to the other.  Elevations average around 2000 ft (610 m).  

The treks with the Scouts are all training treks for their High Adventure trip to Philmont Scout Reservation in New Mexico next year.  There was a lot of instruction at these events, so hiking miles were somewhat reduced.  Actual hiking at each event consisted of about 10 miles (16 km).  Two events had moisture, with the one weekend raining the entire time. 

The Allegheny National Forest treks occurred in June and early July.  Both weekends consisted of hiking about 20 miles (32 km) with fully loaded packs.  Due to the training nature of the hikes, I ended up with a lot more stuff than I normally would ever have on a backpack trip.  Although I didn't weigh my pack (pack contents was a "work in progress"), it was at least 45 lb (20 kg).  Weather was beautiful on both treks, partially cloudy to mostly sunny days with air temperature 85F (29 C) during the day and 55 F (13 C) at night.

I am an avid day hiker, averaging hikes 3-days-a-week year-round.  Day hikes during the test period varied from short day trips of 2 - 5 miles (3 - 8 km) to full day treks of 10 -15 miles (16 - 24 km).  On many of the dayhikes, I carried either a small daypack or lumbar pack. My loads varied from 4 lb (1.8 kg) to 25 lb (11.3 kg).

Results

Four rolls of McNett's Tenacious Sealing and Repair Tape shipped for this test series.  Thus far, I have used a complete roll and I'm approximately 50% into a second roll.  Each roll comes in its own storage tube.  The tube is light blue in color and translucent.  I took no special precautions when handling or storing the tape.   I simply applied the tape in each application and stored it with the rest of my gear in whatever pack I was using.  The tape stayed in very good condition throughout the test.  Whenever I extracted the tape from the tube for use, it was always clean, with no litter or lint stuck to it.  I believe this was due to the nice backer paper used on the tape to protect the adhesive as well as the storage tube.  The tube protected the tape, allowing no accidental separation of the tape from the backer paper.  The tube survived the test, being passed from pack to pack; simply tossed in the bottom and subject to all sorts of abuse.  It can be reused when the tape is gone to store something else.

Results are all positive, although not all the same.  The Tenacious Tape adhered to everything I tried it on, but it began to separate from the material sooner on some items, depending on the nature and characteristics of the material.

  • My NEOS Trekker boots are made from coated nylon. I experienced a small tear from a crampon some time ago. This was the first item I patched with the Tenacious Tape. I'm pleased to report that it is still holding soundly. I patched both the inside and outside of the tear.
  • I tested the Tenacious Tape on two different types of gloves: one was made of neoprene; the other was made of wool. Both were torn/worn on a finger. The tape really didn't last too long in either application. Both areas were subject to constant stress from moving and the tape quickly began to lift around the corners as the gloves went through wet/dry cycles. For a day or so though, the tape repair would work in a pinch.
  • The neoprene cover on my backpack. The item was torn some time ago from an errant branch hanging too low (it couldn't have been me not getting low enough!). Again, I patched both sides of the tear. This spot has very little stress, but exposed to the elements. The patches are still holding, yet the corners are curling just a bit.
  • Nylon rain fly and several tears on the Scout equipment. These are not expensive tents. All are nylon. Many had been torn for years. I through some Tenacious Tape at all of them - eight tents in all.   I used it as an opportunity to teach the scouts about equipment care. The tape held and is holding very well for the most part.  It makes for a poor repair on stake out loops, but works great on most other repairs, even bathtub floors inside the tent.
  • The cotton canvas covering on my old pop-up camper. This is holding up great, even better than the duct tape that was on another small tear. I replaced that too with the Tenacious Tape!
  • Pool toys! Although not permanent, it got us through a broken floatie at my sister-in-law's house and prevented lots of tears from my 3-year-old!
  • First Aid.  On one of our hikes, one of the scouts tore his heel up pretty good from his new boots.  We couldn't keep Moleskin in place at all.  I made a heel cup out of the Tenacious Tape and applied it over a Moleskin doughnut.  It worked great!  I asked his mother how he did at home removing it.  She reported that there was "very little residue on his skin from the tape".
  • Leaky water bottle.  I cracked a water bottle when it collided with a rock outcropping on a hike.  I wrapped some Tenacious Tape around the bottle a few times and it stopped the leak.  I used it all weekend that way and it held great!

Test Summary

I have used McNett's Tenacious Tape on everything I could think of where I would have applied duct tape over the last four months relating to backpacking.  I have been very, very pleased with the tape's performance.  It doesn't yellow, even in direct sunlight, holds well, and is easy to use and store.  If it has to be removed, it can be cleanly, leaving virtually no residue. 

Thank you BGT and McNett for a very fun test on a fine product that works!

Tim

 




Read more reviews of McNett Corporation gear
Read more gear reviews by Tim Coughlin

Reviews > Do It Yourself > Repair Kits > McNett Tenacious Tape > Tim Coughlin > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson