BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Field Report

Smith Theory Sunglasses
Field Report
May 23, 2005

Contents:
     Tester Information
     Product Information
     Report

Tester Information

Name: Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Location: Los Altos, CA

Age/Sex: 27/Female

Height: 5'5" (1.65 m)

Weight: 125 lb (57 kg)

Email: rebecca@backpackgeartest.org

Website: http://www.calipidder.com

I began backpacking in the summer of 2000 after moving to California. Although I started off carrying everything but the kitchen sink, my style has shifted to lightweight gear and techniques, though I am known to carry a few luxury items.   First in my heart is summer backpacking, but I also enjoy snowshoeing, skiing, and snowcamping, as well as long dayhikes and peak climbing.  I spend time outside during weekends year-round in the deserts and mountains of California. My weekend hikes are often 'spur-of-the-moment', and usually occur in and around Yosemite National Park, Desolation Wilderness (near Lake Tahoe), and Sonora Pass in the Sierra Nevada mountains, as well as Lassen National Park and Mt. Shasta area in the Southern Cascades.

Product Information

Name: Smith Theory Sunglasses

Manufacturer: Smith Optics

Manufacturer website: www.smithoptics.com

Year of Manufacture: 2005

Listed Weight: none 

Measured weight: 0.6 oz/17 g

MSRP: $99 to $129 USD, depending on lens/frame combination.

 

Theory front view
 
The Smith Theory sunglasses are part of Smith's Interchangeable lens series.  This series, consisting of 14 different frame styles at the time of this writing, allows the user to change among different lenses depending on the conditions in which they will be using the glasses.  There are several frame colors and lens combinations to choose among.
 

Field Report

Unlike most backpacking gear, sunglasses are something that I use daily.  As a resident of the sunny state of California sunglasses are needed all the time, whether it's for a quick walk to the produce stand, driving to work, jogging, hiking, skiing, or anything else!  Even in the rainy winter season I always keep sunglasses at hand.  This means that the Smith Theory sunglasses have gotten a large amount of use in a wide variety of conditions in the Field Testing period - more use than I am used to writing about in my reports about backpacking-only gear!

These activities and field conditions include:

  • Hiking and backpacking in the San Francisco Bay area:  During the past couple of months most of my local park hiking has been on the east side of the Santa Cruz mountains, which are usually dry grassy two-track style trails.  In the summer these trails can be miserably hot, but in the spring these are great trails to get out and see some wildflowers in the warm sun before things get too hot.  One backpacking trip to Henry Coe State Park also occurred, with similar terrain and some hot and sunny weather.  There is barely any flat trail in Henry Coe, so much of the hiking is never ending sweaty uphill slogs.
  • Snowshoeing in Lassen National Park: I spent an overnight in Lassen with a group of twelve people.  It was a lovely sunny weekend on the fresh snow, with the sun beating down enough to make me snowshoe in a summer tank top!   
  • Snowshoeing in North Tahoe to Loch Leven Lakes: I lucked out this winter and had warm sunny weather for most of my outings.  Until recently, that is, where we spent a late season overnight in the snow that brought rain.   
  • Two days of day trips on the snow in the Tahoe area, one on cross country skis and the other on snowshoes.   Conditions were just like those in Lassen National Park.
  • Jogging around home:  Three days a week I jog around the local neighborhood after work.  This is usually early evening and the sun is still pretty hot, so I sweat a lot.
  • Bay-to-Breakers party/race in San Francisco:  I wore the Theory sunglasses during the Bay-to-Breakers 7.5 mile (12 km) race in San Francisco.  I wasn't a runner; I was a "back of the pack" person, taking part in the moving block party element of the fun.  It was sunny, then sprinkly, then foggy, and the crowd was huge and I was jostled around quite a bit.
  • Daily around-town wear: Again, one advantage to sunglasses is that I can use them every day in California.  I keep these glasses on the table right next to my front door and put them on whenever I walk outside, whether it is for a jog, or to drive somewhere.

While seemingly a simple piece of gear, there is a lot to talk about when it comes to these sunglasses.  I've broken down this report into the following sections:

  • Fit and Function
  • Interchangeable Lenses
  • Storage
  • Wear and Tear

Fit and Function

me in the theoriesThe single most important thing I look for in a pair of sunglasses is the answer to this question: Do they protect my eyes comfortably?  Due to the time I spend in the snow and at high altitude, I must have sunglasses that will protect my somewhat light-sensitive eyes.  I wear contacts and seem to react more strongly to bright light and reflected light than my husband, who does not wear contacts.   And, due to the fact that when I am in these conditions I am usually doing an active sport, I must have glasses that are comfortable and well-fitting as well.

I have a narrow face and that means most glasses I use are too wide.  Wide glasses will wobble and let in too much light around the sides, which is not good!  The Theory glasses, which Smith lists as having a small/medium fit, are the first glasses I've had that don't have a big gap around the temple.  They slide on snug around my face and stay put no matter what I am doing.  I've taken tumbles on skis, postholed in my snowshoes, jogged while sweating like crazy, trudged up steep trails while sweating and losing my footing, and still they won't budge.  The nose and temple pad material, combined with the snug fit, do a perfect job at keeping the glasses in place.  I frequently forget that I'm wearing them.  I've said this before - if I forget I'm wearing something that is the best sign of good fit and comfort, whether it is a backpack, pants, or sunglasses.  The first couple times I wore them I noticed a small amount of pinching behind my ears after hours and hours of wear, but this has gone away with use.

I've worn the Theory sunglasses with two types of hats: a baseball style cap and wide-brimmed sun/rain hats.  The arms of the sunglasses extend back far enough that the baseball cap doesn't fit too well with them, but the two wide-brimmed hats I have used with them have worked quite well.

My mom told me never to rest glasses on the top of my head since I would surely lose them/drop them/break them.  Sorry Mom, but I do this frequently with sunglasses.  Since I wear them pretty much everywhere, I'll simply slide them up on my head when I walk into a store or crawl into my tent, among other reasons.  The temple pads and shape of the frames keep them in place here, and I've never felt like they are at risk of falling off of my head.  And, more importantly, they never have.

There is a certain amount of light leakage around the bottom and lower outside of the standard Theory lenses.  It is minimal and doesn't bother me too much.  The Theory Max lenses eliminate the majority of the light leakage by having an extended lens that covers just the right spot where the light leaks through on the lower outside.  There is still a small amount of light leakage on the bottom with the Theory Max lenses.  The photo below shows the regular Theory lens (left) and the Theory Max lens (right).  Notice the Theory Max has more coverage to the bottom and outside of the lens.

Theory vs theory max

Interchangeable Lenses

Lens removalThe lens changing procedure has gotten much, much easier with time.  Actually, after the first two or three changes, the process became very quick and simple.  I give the lens a tug (as shown in the photo to the right) to remove it, and the opposite motion to snap a new lens into place.  Either the track has smoothed out a bit, or I have gotten the 'feel' for it now.  Probably a little bit of both.  In any case, it has become second nature and I no longer feel nervous that I am hurting the glasses.  Once in place, the lenses feel tight and secure - not once have I felt like the lenses were loose or that they would come unsecured.

How practical is the lens interchangeability feature?  As described in my Initial Report, I received the following lenses with the Theory sunglasses.  Each lens has a Visible Light Transmission (VLT) rate, which Smith defines as the percentage of visible light allowed to reach the eye. All lenses included with my test set have 100% UVA and UVB protection.

  • Sienna Brown (Theory and Theory Max):  This lens shade is good for sunny and slightly overcast conditions.  The brown tint is supposed to enhance depth perception.  VLT= 18%. 
  • Yellow (Theory and Theory Max):  Increases seeing ability in flat and low light conditions.   VLT = 68%
  • Rose Copper 36 (Theory): Best for widest variety of conditions.  VLT = 36%
  • Sienna Brown Polarized (Theory):  Similar to the regular Sienna Brown, but with polarization that cuts 99% or reflected light.  VLT = 15%

I have found myself using two of these lenses 90% of the time.  Since it is the end of the rainy season in California there have been some cloudy and rainy days during the testing period.  On these gloomy days I choose to use the Rose Copper lenses.  I find that they provide a cheery view of a dismal day, and if the sun decides to poke out they still give me protection.  I can keep them on when it's clouding up and I don't feel like I'm left in the dark - I can still see clearly.  Most other sunglasses I have used would be too dark to use when the clouds came out, so I'd be constantly putting them on and taking them off at this time of year.  This is not necessary with the lovely Rose Copper lenses.  Colors, especially greens, become very vibrant when viewed through these lenses.   My other favorite lenses are the Sienna Brown Polarized.  I have used these extensively on the snow and have loved them and the protection they provide.  They are always my first choice on bright sunny days.  If I don't want to be bothered by light leaks, but don't need the polarization, I will use the bigger Sienna Brown Theory Max lenses.  I wish that the Sienna Brown Theory Max lenses were also polarized, which would give me the best of both worlds.   I have found little use for the yellow lenses, but if I have a chance to go jogging in the rain I will definitely try them in those conditions.

I've found that I like to switch the lenses out in the safety of my own home.  I look at the weather report and determine which lenses will be the most appropriate for the conditions I will be in, then pick which lens I will use.  I don't carry lens changes with me on the trail, mostly because I'm nervous that I will break them, lose them, or hurt them if I try to switch them out in the backcountry with dirty hands.  I like changing them at home, over a carpeted surface, with my lens cleaning cloth nearby.   It's just simpler that way.  If I were heading out for several days I would definitely consider bringing multiple sets of lenses, but right now I prefer to change them at home.

Storage

The standard case provided with the Theory sunglasses is quite nice, but not at all what I want for a pair of sport glasses.  The standard case is soft, but has great pockets for storing two sets of extra lenses.  But, I tend to throw my glasses in purses, backpacks, car seats, and other dangerous places.  Therefore I need a hard case for any sunglasses that I use or they won't last very long!  My solution is that I leave the Smith case at home on a safe shelf as storage for the extra lenses (photo on the right - note the extra lens pockets).  The sunglasses themselves are carried in a hard shelled case (photo on the left).  I can put them away in the hard case and toss them willy-nilly into a pack or tent without worrying about crushing them with gear or my knees.

 

Hard shelled casesoft shelled case


Wear and Tear

Daily use of the Theory sunglasses - putting them on and taking them off, propping them up on my head, tossing them on tables, car seats, dashboards, etc, getting covered with snow and dust - and they still look brand new!  The lenses and frames both look like the day they were received.  I am incredibly pleased with the way these glasses have handled regular and tough use. For being so lightweight, with the interchangeable lens function, these things are bombproof.  Well, I haven't exactly gone out of my way to drop them on concrete to test this, but they certainly haven't received special treatment either.  I'm not purposefully rough with my gear, but I also don't treat it with kid gloves.  I expect gear intended for outdoor use to withstand the type of abuse typical of outdoor sports, and these glasses have performed perfectly.  In my Initial Report I mentioned being concerned about the flexible Grilamid material, and if it would become loose over time.  So far there has been no deterioration in the fit at all.  I'll discuss this in further detail in the Long Term Report - once I have four more months of every day use I should be able to comment further about the durability of the Theory sunglasses.


In the short two months I have been using the Smith Theory sunglasses I have been incredibly pleased with the fit, performance, and quality.  The interchangeable lenses have been fun to play with an I enjoy having the option of different lenses with the comfortable frames.  I expect that the rest of the test period will provide more positive experiences with these glasses, and I look forward to reporting on their long term performance.

 

 



Read more reviews of Smith gear
Read more gear reviews by Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson