BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Initial Report

Smith Theory Sunglasses
Initial Report
March 2, 2005

Contents:
     Tester Information
     Product Information
     Report

Tester Information

Name: Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Location: Los Altos, CA

Age/Sex: 27/Female

Height: 5'5" (1.65 m)

Weight: 125 lb (59 kg)

Email: rebecca@backpackgeartest.org

Website: http://www.calipidder.com

I began backpacking in the summer of 2000 after moving to California. Although I started off carrying everything but the kitchen sink, my style has shifted to lightweight gear and techniques, though I am known to carry a few luxury items.   First in my heart is summer backpacking, but I also enjoy snowshoeing, skiing, and snowcamping, as well as long dayhikes and peak climbing.  I spend time outside during weekends year-round in the deserts and mountains of California. My weekend hikes are often 'spur-of-the-moment', and usually occur in and around Yosemite National Park, Desolation Wilderness (near Lake Tahoe), and Sonora Pass in the Sierra Nevada mountains, as well as Lassen National Park and Mt. Shasta area in the Southern Cascades.

Product Information

Name: Smith Theory Sunglasses

Manufacturer: Smith Optics

Manufacturer website: www.smithoptics.com

Year of Manufacture: 2005

Listed Weight: none 

Measured weight: 0.6 oz/17 g

MSRP: $99 to $129, depending on lens/frame combination.

 

Theory front view
 
The Smith Theory sunglasses are part of Smith's Interchangeable lens series.  This series, consisting of 14 different frame styles at the time of this writing, allows the user to change among different lenses depending on the conditions in which they will be using the glasses.  There are several frame colors and lens combinations to choose among.
 

Initial Report

Standard set of lensesThe Smith Optics Theory Interchangeable lens sunglasses are sport glasses intended for a wide range of uses.  The Theory is the same as the Axis frame, with the Axis being the larger fit and the Theory being the smaller of the two.   The frame is designed to maximize peripheral vision while minimizing sun exposure, or as I like to call it, "light leaks."  The Theory boasts eight different standard frame/lens combinations made up of six frame designs and twelve lens choices.  Any lens can be purchased to enhance the standard set, and to customize the glasses to any user's particular frame and lens combination desire.

The Theory frame is a rimless design made with Smith's proprietary Grilamid nylon.  Of the eight different standard combinations, I chose the frame color Purple Fade, which comes with three Carbonic lens colors in Sienna Brown, RC36 (rose copper), and Yellow (all three are shown in the photo to the left).  The frame has no bottom to it, allowing for lenses to be snapped in and out.  The bottom of the lens sits directly against the skin and makes up the bottom of the 'frame'.  Smith uses the term 'rimless' to describe frames of this type. 

Bendable FrameThe special Grilamid material that makes up the frame deserves further discussion.  According to Smith, Grilamid is, "Maximum comfort. Maximum flexibility.  Maximum toughness.  Maximum sunscreen/lotion resistance...Well-suited for sport or casual use in hot or cold temps."  I understand that one would want sport sunglasses frames to be tough and comfortable, but...flexible?  I picked up the frames and gently pulled the end of one of the arms outward, in an opposite direction of the natural curve of the frame.  It easily bent outwards and then bounced back to its original position.  I am so used to babying my sunglasses that I had been handling these so gently that I didn't notice the frame flexibility until trying it.  This is an amazing property of the material used for the frames and I look forward to trying these out in the field.  I wonder if cold temperatures will affect the frame flexibility.   

When the arms are extended the frames form a curved shape that slides nicely around my head.  They fit snug but not too tight.  Three things make these glasses stay put - one is the wraparound design that hugs my head, the other is the hydrophilic nose and temple pads which grip securely and prevent slipping, and the third is the flexibility of the Grilamid frame.  The glasses are snug enough that shaking my head and jumping around do not budge them.  We'll see how they do when I take a tumble on my skis, or while jogging down a bumpy trail and sweating!

While the frames fit snug and comfortably, they are a little wide for my face at the front.  I don't think of myself as having a particularly narrow face, but sunglasses shopping has shown me otherwise.  Nearly every pair of glasses I try on is too wide.  In comparison to my general experiences, the Theory glasses definitely have a narrower fit than most sports glasses I have tried on in the past, but they aren't significantly smaller, and in fact still are a little wide for my face.  The curving arc of the frame shape curves a little too far away from my face between my eyes and temples.

This means there is a bit of light leakage.  The wrap design and wide temples help prevent this, but light definitely gets through.  I am looking forward to trying the Theory Max and polarized lenses when out on snow and highly reflective conditions, to see if the reflected light bothers me. 

Smith sunglasses caseAlso included with the Theory glasses was a soft case with convenient pockets for the extra lenses.  This case, pictured above, does not offer heavy duty protection, so I will likely switch to a harder case since I like to toss my sunglasses in my packs and purses without worrying about crushing them.  Similarly, the lens pockets are very nice and protect from scratching and general use, but I don't think the case would protect them well when thrown in the bottom of a pack.

Finally, the last thing included in the box was an information sheet about changing the lenses, as well as a paper describing the lifetime guarantee.  As a bonus there is also a Smith sticker in the case.  I think I'll put that on my car next to all of my other stickers! 

For testing, I also received a set of polarized brown lenses, as well as two pairs of Theory Max lenses in Yellow and Sienna Brown.  The Theory Max lenses fit in the Theory frames but are a bit larger (in length) than the standard Theory lenses and therefore are supposed to provide more coverage.  The three extra lens sets each come with their own drawstring bag for protection, but the bag is not stiff or padded.  I intend these to be used as nothing more than dust covers and light scratch protection.  I will find a hard case for carrying these lenses to protect them better.

Entire testing setThe extra lens boxes came with the Lifetime Guarantee paper and a sticker, but no instructions on how to change them.  Presumably, anyone who buys the extra lenses already has the frames which came with the instructions.  Fortunately, if the instructions are lost they can be found on the Smith website.  As I will discuss later, it's a rather straightforward process and once it's done once the instructions shouldn't be needed again.

One piece of information I looked for in the included information but did not find was details about the different lenses.  With six sets of lenses to use with these glasses, it leaves me wondering what the best conditions are for each of the lenses.  What are the best conditions for the yellow lenses?  How about the polarized sienna brown vs. the non-polarized?   Do the advantages of switching out lenses outweigh the hassle of doing it?  Is it a hassle to change them in the first place?

Since this information wasn't provided with the packaging, my next step to find this information was to look on the Smith Optics website.  After a few seconds of poking around I found a page on lens technology which contained a list of the lenses and their specifications and best uses.  From this page I learned the following about the lenses that I will be using with the Theory frames.  Each lens has a Visible Light Transmission (VLT) rate, which Smith defines as the percentage of visible light allowed to reach the eye. All lenses included with my test set have 100% UVA and UVB protection.

  • Sienna Brown (Theory and Theory Max):  This lens shade is good for sunny and slightly overcast conditions.  The brown tint is supposed to enhance depth perception.  VLT= 18%. 
  • Yellow (Theory and Theory Max):  Increases seeing ability in flat and low light conditions.   VLT = 68%
  • RC36 (Theory): Best for widest variety of conditions.  VLT = 36%
  • Sienna Brown Polarized (Theory):  Similar to the regular Sienna Brown, but with polarization that cuts 99% or reflected light.  VLT = 15%

The ability to switch lenses depending on the conditions I encounter is new to me.  I have been aware of the Interchangeable lens sunglasses on the market, but I have never owned or used a pair.  Naturally then, the first thing I did after opening the box was figure out how to change the lenses.  The instruction sheet is pretty straightforward.  I have to simply hold the framed in the center (at the nose), then grip the center of the lens with my other hand and pull it downward until it snaps out.  To put in a new lens, I do the opposite. 

Lens removalThat sounds simple enough, right?  I gripped the glasses exactly as the instructions said.  I pulled on the lens and it felt superglued into place.  I tugged a bit harder, then a bit harder.  I was getting a bit nervous that I might break the lens.  Just as I was about to give up in fear of breaking the lens it snapped out with a clean pop.  I tried putting it back in.  I had to apply more pressure to snap it back in than when I took it out.  I did the process of removing and reinstalling the lenses a few times and it got a bit easier.  I don't know if it is because the glasses were 'breaking in' or if I was just getting used to the right 'feel' to pop them out and in.  There is a note at the bottom of the instructions that says it will get easier with time - I sure hope so!  On the other hand, I am glad the lenses are in there tightly because I'm not worried about them falling out.

Test Plan

So, what do I have in store for these puppies for the next six months?  Sunglasses practically have a permanent place on my face since I live in California.  One of the advantages to living here is the amazing amount of sunshine - I rarely step out the door without putting on a pair of shades.  Occasionally we get long cloudy rainy spurts, but I still keep my sunglasses near at all times because you never know when that beautiful California sun will shine through.

It's one thing to wear shades during the day while driving around and running errands.  It's another thing to wear the same shades while playing.  My basic plan for the next six months it to wear the Theory sunglasses whenever I am outside, be it driving to work or skiing in the mountains.  I intend to wear them while snowshoeing, skiing, hiking, backpacking, running, peak climbing, rock climbing, and any other activity that sounds like fun.  On the weekends they'll be worn in snowstorms as well as warm sunny fresh powder days in the Sierra Nevada and Southern Cascade mountains.  During the week they'll be worn hiking in my local area, where the sun shines brightly most days of the year.  As summer emerges in the Sierra they'll be worn hiking and backpacking at high altitude where the sun is intense and good eye protection is absolutely necessary.

Even if I'm wearing these glasses every day and for countless activities, I have to have a test plan for them.  What kind of things will I be paying attention to while I'm wearing them?

  • First things first - fit.  Can I wear these glasses for 10 hours a day while hiking and will they still feel good?  Do they fit too tightly?  Too loosely?  Do they pinch?  Do they move around?  Do they stay put?  Do I remember I'm wearing them?  I like it when I forget I'm wearing something, be it a jacket, a pack, or sunglasses.  To me that means the item fits perfectly.  If I don't notice I'm wearing the Theorys I'll be happy.
  • The second most important thing, in my opinion, are the various lenses.  This encompasses many things that need to be evaluated, including how easy it is to change out lenses, how different lenses work in different conditions, how the repeated changing of the lenses wears and tears both the frames and the lenses, and other issues that may come up in relation to the interchangeability of the lenses.
  • Durability of the frames.  With the flexible Grilamid material, I am looking forward to evaluating any wear and tear the frames may encounter.  Of course I will not purposely try to hurt them, but occasional mishaps occur, especially with sunglasses.  How well do the frames take tossing around, being moved up to the top of my head and back down to my face?  Do the joints loosen so the frames won't fit as tightly as they get older?  Will the flexible material deteriorate or become more brittle with time?
  • Field use.  How do these glasses perform overall when I am active?  I'll be in the snow, sun, and everything in between while wearing the Theorys.  How do they perform?  Do I get a lot of annoying light leakage or do they block most of the direct sun?  Do they slide down my nose or stay put?  Are they easy to slide up on my head when running indoors for a moment, or in a shady spot?  My mom told me never to do that because I would lose and break glasses that way, but I still do it frequently.  Sorry mom! 

I am really excited to wear these glasses for the next six months.  The Interchangeable lenses are a new experience for me and I am very curious as to how I will use this feature.  I hope that my experiences and subsequent reports will provide Smith Optics and the backpacking community with information that is valuable.  Thank you to Smith Optics for this testing opportunity with BackpackGearTest.org.

 



Read more reviews of Smith gear
Read more gear reviews by Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Initial Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson