BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Long Term Report

Smith Theory Sunglasses
Long Term Report
September 20, 2005

Contents:
     Tester Information
     Product Information
     Report

Tester Information

Name: Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

Location: Los Altos, CA

Age/Sex: 27/Female

Height: 5'5" (1.65 m)

Weight: 125 lb (57 kg)

Email: rebecca@backpackgeartest.org

Website: http://www.calipidder.com

I began backpacking in the summer of 2000 after moving to California. Although I started off carrying everything but the kitchen sink, my style has shifted to lightweight gear and techniques, though I am known to carry a few luxury items.   First in my heart is summer backpacking, but I also enjoy snowshoeing, skiing, and snowcamping, as well as long dayhikes and peak climbing.  I spend time outside during weekends year-round in the deserts and mountains of California. My weekend hikes are often 'spur-of-the-moment', and usually occur in and around Yosemite National Park, Desolation Wilderness (near Lake Tahoe), and Sonora Pass in the Sierra Nevada mountains, as well as Lassen National Park and Mt. Shasta area in the Southern Cascades.

Product Information

Name: Smith Theory Sunglasses

Manufacturer: Smith Optics

Manufacturer website: www.smithoptics.com

Year of Manufacture: 2005

Listed Weight: none 

Measured weight: 0.6 oz/17 g

MSRP: $99 to $129 USD, depending on lens/frame combination.

 

Theory front view
 
The Smith Theory sunglasses are part of Smith's Interchangeable lens series.  This series, consisting of 14 different frame styles at the time of this writing, allows the user to change among different lenses depending on the conditions in which they will be using the glasses.  There are several frame colors and lens combinations to choose among.
 

Long Term Report

For the past six months the Smith Theory Sunglasses have been my primary sunglasses for athletic wear. Since the Field Report they have been worn on several weekend backpacking trips in the Sierra Nevada, countless dayhikes in the San Francisco Bay area and Lava Beds National Monument, kayaking and hiking the dunes on Lake Michigan, and running in my neighborhood three mornings a week.

    Comfort

    These glasses are very comfortable for athletic use. In fact, I frequently forget that I am wearing them! When I am backpacking in the Sierra the early morning sun can be quite bright, so they are one of the first things I put on in the mornings. They have to stay on all day until the sun goes down and through all kinds of activity. Even after a full day of use I don't notice them - I'll think it's getting dark out early until I remember (or someone reminds me) that I still have my sunglasses on. I'm very happy to have a pair of glasses that I can wear all day without feeling pinched. I attribute the comfort to the 'bendy' material of the arms. They fit snug but have the flexibility so that they don't squeeze my head too tight. I wear them regularly while running. Even when I am sweating heavily and jogging on pavement (which jolts the body a bit) they don't budge and I don't notice them.

    Ouside of CaveI put the Theorys up on my head all of the time. I love how they will stay put - this was especially nice in Lava beds National Monument, where we were hiking between caves. Constantly going in and out of the dark can be a pain if you don't have a quick place to stash the sunglasses. In my case, that was my head. If we were going into small caves I'd put them in a case for protection.

    Interchangeable Lenses

    I don't have much to add about the lens interchangeability since my comments in the Field Report. In sunshiney California we are fortunate enough to not have to deal with clouds and rain through the summer. I found the Rose Copper lenses to be very nice in the cloudy winter conditions in the San Francisco Bay area, but once the summer sun appeared I put in the brown polarized lenses and rarely needed to change them. These lenses are perfect in the bright sun, especially at altitude in the Sierra, and I have no desire to switch to the yellow or Rose Copper lenses until the clouds appear again this winter. I am very happy that I have this option. The polarized lenses are too dark for local use in the winter, and it is nice to be able to use the same glasses year-round, simply by changing out the lenses. I will still use the polarized brown lenses for playing on the snow in the Sierra this winter.

    In the last weekend of the Long Term Test period I wore the brown polarized lenses on a hike along a bluff over the Pacific Ocean on the foggy coast just north of San Francisco. When the sun finally came out I looked out on the shimmery water and noticed that something was a bit off. I tilted my head a few degrees to the right and then the left. I did it again with my right eye closed, then my left eye. I noticed that the polarization, which prevents the reflected light from passing through the glasses, was a bit off between the lenses. The right lens had the maximum filter when my head was straight. In order for the left lens to block the most reflected light I had to tilt my head about ten degrees to the left. I asked a friend (and fellow BGT tester) who I was with to try it. He also observed that the polarization in the lenses was off.

    Since the shimmery surface of the Pacific Ocean doesn't provide a smooth surface for reflected light, I wanted to test this observation another way. At home, I took another pair of polarized glasses that I own (the Smith Spawns) and held the Theory brown polarized lenses up to them one by one. The right lens blocked all light when held at a 90 degree angle to the right lens of the Spawn. This is what is expected in polarized lenses. The left Theory lens, when held at a 90 degree angle to the right lens of the Spawn still let a little light through. I had to turn it about 10 degrees for the maximum blockage. This unscientific test confirmed what I saw last week when looking at the water - the polarization in the Theory lenses are off from each other by about 10 degrees.

    This isn't a big deal to me - I wore them for six months before noticing it at all. I have worn them on the snow, while kayaking, and while at the beach, and even in those conditions where there was a lot of reflected light I didn't notice it. It certainly doesn't bother me enough to stop wearing them, and I'm still looking forward to wearing them on the reflective snow when the sun is out this winter.


    Wear and Tear

    Sunglasses that I use for backpacking, running, and hiking must be durable. I always have the best intentions to treat my sunglasses carefully, but it is inevitable that I'll drop them on granite, kneel on them in my tent, or drop them in the dirt. Usually all three happen in the span of a weekend backpacking trip. So far the Theorys have taken these beatings in stride. The lenses I use the most frequently, the polarized brown lenses, have a few very minor scratches and knicks. They do not bother me when I am wearing the glasses, and I have to look at them carefully in just the right light in order to see the damage. Considering the number of times I've dropped them around camp (at least three that I can remember), they look remarkably good! The frames don't even look used - I can't find any scratches or markings. Even the painted text on the inside of arms hasn't faded. The nose and ear padding is clean and smooth, just as it was when they were new. They definitely don't look as used as they actually are.

    Me in camp with the smithsI have gotten into the habit of only changing the lenses at home. I don't feel comfortable doing this in the backcountry where I may drop or break lenses more easily.  At home I can change them with clean hands and over a soft surface, so before I head out on a trip I pick the lenses that are the most appropriate for the conditions.  I believe this has helped keep the lenses in good condition.

    Conclusions

    The Smith Theory Sunglasses are, in my opinion, the perfect outdoor glasses.  They are extremely comfortable, durable, and most importantly stay put on my face whether I'm hopping boulders in Yosemite, jogging down my paved street, or hiking down a trail while covered in sweat.  They do a good job at keeping out the light and protecting the eyes, especially when the Theory Max lenses are used.  The different lens options allow me to wear them year-round, perfect for the semi-cloudy conditions that are common in winter around here. 

    As my second pair of Smith sunglasses, I am very impressed with the quality and design of their glasses and look forward to using them for many years to come.

     

     



    Read more reviews of Smith gear
    Read more gear reviews by Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd

    Reviews > Eye Protection > Sun Glasses > Smith Theory > Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd > Long Term Report



    All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
    BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson