| |
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
|
|
This Long-Term
Report is the final report of a series of three reports
written over a six-month test period. The information found here should be
taken in conjunction with the information found in the Initial
Report and Field
Report. |
Tester
Biographical Information
| Name: |
Tim Coughlin |
| Gender: |
Male |
| Height: |
5 ft 11 in (1.8 m) |
| Weight: |
180 lb (82 kg) |
| Age: |
42 |
| Email: |
TCoug7<at>yahoo<dot>com |
| Test Location: |
Western New York, Northern Pennsylvania, Adirondack
Mountains |
| State: |
New York |
| Country: |
United States |
Backpacking Background:
I have been an active backpacker for 28 years, with experience
hiking in many parts of the continental United States and Canada. Most of
my time is spent in the Northeast, especially the Adirondack region of New
York. I am a seasoned veteran to 3-season backpacking, and I’m expanding
my resume to include winter backpacking. I would classify myself as a
"lightweight" backpacker, but always working towards the "ultralight" title.
I am an avid four-season dayhiker.
Product
Information
| Name: |
Paramount Waffle Stomper |
| Model
Number: |
MWH800BR |
| Manufacturer: |
Dunham Boot Maker |
| Web Site: |
www.dunhambootmakers.com |
| Date of
Manufacture: |
2004 |
|
Size
Tested: |
11 D (US sizing), 10.5 (UK), 45
(Euro) |
| Published
Weight: |
1 lb 10 oz (737 g) |
|
Measured
Weight: |
1 lb 14 oz / boot (850 g) 3 lb 12
oz / pair (1.7 kg) |
| Measured Length of
Laces: |
93 in (236 cm) |
| Color: |
Dark brown leather with red/gray/black rubber
sole and red or brown laces. |
| Warranty: |
Unconditional Satisfaction Guarantee |
| MSRP: |
$134.99 - US
currency |
Specifications:
- Vibram Sole
- Polyurethane Midsole
- Tapered Nylon Insole Board
- ABSORB Footbed
- Full Grain Waterproof Leather
- Seam Sealed
- Ski-flap Gusseted Tongue
- External TPU Heel Counter
- Choice of Red or Brown Laces
Long-Term Results
Field Information:
Six months
of testing has taken my Waffle Stompers and me from the coast of South Carolina
to the peaks of the highest mountains in New York. Since the Field Report in
May, I estimate that I've logged another 500 miles (800 km) on my boots – at
least. Long-term testing occurred right through the heart of summer.
Temperatures ranged from near freezing (at night, in the mountains) to 90F (32
C). Terrain traveled has been everything from sandy paths, dirt trails, and
grassy meadows to boulder fields, sheer granite mountains and mud-sucking paths.
I've worn my Waffle Stompers while canoeing, and whitewater rafting. I've hiked
in my boots carrying loads as heavy as 50 lb (23 kg) at times, and other times I
carried nothing but a water bottle. I've worn them across creeks only a few
inches (5 cm) deep, as well as through raging water up to my thighs. Early on in
the test series, I snowshoed in my boots; since then I've climbed rocks in them,
played ball in them, and even went to church in
them.
Test
Results:
In the beginning of the test series, I felt the Waffle
Stompers fit nicely right out of the box, albeit somewhat stiff. At the end of
the test series, I still find the Waffle Stompers to fit nicely, yet somewhat
stiff. Don't get me wrong; the boots have broken in beautifully. The leather has
softened up, and the padding has taken on the shape of my foot. But, the TPU
heel counter is just as stiff as it was six months ago. This leads to an overall
stiff feeling when first putting on the boots. Yet, I can honestly say this is
about as long as the feeling lasts. As I begin to walk in them, the stiff
feeling quickly diminishes and I soon forget about it. I can also say that I've
NEVER experienced any blisters on my feet! Actually, the only time I felt
so much as a hot spot was due to a small pebble in my shoe, not from the boot
itself. The Waffle Stompers make for very comfortable boots. I've worn them on
four occasions where I hiked over 20 miles (32 km) in a day. My legs don't tire
from these boots. I like them best wearing a thicker hiking sock, although I've
worn them many times in white cotton socks as well.
The Paramount Waffle
Stompers come treated with waterproofing. I questioned its effectiveness over
the long haul as the boots became scuffed and scratched. Even though the leather
has many gouges and gashes, they are still water tight. As recently as two weeks
ago, I wore my Waffle Stompers in ankle deep water for over an hour, and my feet
stayed dry. The boots are warm and don't breathe well, as expected. When I'm out
hiking though, I don't even notice it. When I stop, I simply remove my boots and
let my "dogs" breathe. It works for me.
These boots offer a lot of
support. Many times, I experience pain in the arch of my foot, especially after
a long day with a pack on. Never did my feet ache in these boots, like they do
in light trail hikers or running shoes. The TPU heel counter offers tremendous
lateral stability for the rear of my foot. But my best kudos for these boots, at
least support-wise, is the way my foot is held comfortably in one place. I
credit this to the fit across the metatarsal section of my foot in conjunction
with the heel counter. I've gone up and down the mountains of the Adirondacks,
and never did I have a problem with my heel lifting, my Achilles tendon aching,
or my toes jamming in the front on my boots!
I've become much more
impressed with the traction on these boots as well. I found it was difficult not
to draw direct comparisons with other brand name boots when I was hiking
straight down solid rock for 2000 ft (600 m) and I was the only one in my
group not slipping and sliding. All I can say is that I was confident in my
Waffle Stompers to hold securely, and they always did – whether it was over dry
rock or wet rock colored with algae green. It's that same green that raises
fear in any hiker that has found himself/herself at some point flying through
the air and landing on their butt because they trusted their footing on some
rock colored with the green `kiss of death'. The boots also did a good job
crossing the slippery log bridges that are scattered throughout the High Peaks
Region in the Adirondacks
Durability was a concern, especially in the toe
box area covered with such a small toe guard. This area of the boots has taken
the greatest beating, and looks it. The leather is covered with wear marks and
gouges. Although not as attractive as it was, I'm most impressed with the fact
that the toe areas show no signs of leaking. So far, the gouges only affect the
aesthetics of the boots. Hardware, like lace rings and speed hooks have held up
well. I have bent the speed hooks, but I've bent them back with my Leatherman
with no ill effects. I had a problem in the beginning with the top laces riding
over the top of the tongue, but thanks to a lacing tip by James Triplett in his
Field Report, I haven't had a problem since I adopted James' suggestion of
lacing the top hook then dropping down to the second speed hooks, lacing and
tying off. I like this lacing pattern so much, I lace my other boots like this
as well. I find it very effective and comfortable - thanks
James!
Summary of Field
Experience
The Dunham Paramount Waffle Stompers rock! I love
these boots. They're comfortable, offer all kinds of support and protection,
look good, and have held up great. And what traction they offer! I'd like to see
the toe bumper extended to cover more of the toe box, but other than that I like
them just the way they are. The plastic heel counter works great with snowshoes
too. I can ratchet down on my back straps with no distortion because the heel
counter takes all the stress. These are really nice boots that I will continue
to use for a long, long time to come. One hint: take them off if you have to
wade through deep water. They do take some time to dry out!
Thanks again
to Dunham and BackpackGearTest for the opportunity to test this fine
product.
Tim
Read more reviews of Dunham gear
Read more gear reviews by Tim Coughlin
|