BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Footwear > Footbeds and Insoles > Spenco OAS Day Hiker > Mike Lipay > Initial Report

SPENCO OAS Day Hiker Footbeds - Initial Report

by Mike Lipay - August 5, 2005

Description
Date Arrived August 1, 2005 Spenco Day Hikers
Manufacturer Spenco
Year of Manufacturer 2005
Website http://www.Spenco.com
MSRP None listed
Warranty One Year, Unconditional
Size #3 (Mens US 8-9, Womens US 9-10)
Specifications This series is recommended for Light Hiking / Trail Walking, this being defined by Spenco as a 1-Day trip carrying 0-25 lbs (11 kgs).



Personal Information
Name Mike Lipay
Age 50
Gender Male
Height 5 ft 8 in / 173 cm
Weight 185 lbs / 83.9 kg
Email hikingATwesternpaDOTus
City, State Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Background I started hiking back in the '60s and have spent most of my life in the outdoors. I prefer to hike solo, or with my kids, but also work as a volunteer trail guide for local clubs, and teach hiking and LNT skills through our local community college. I am, by no means, an ultralight backpacker (my external frame pack weighs in at 29-33 lbs / 13-15 kgs); I prefer primitive to tech (hiking staff to trekking poles, compass to GPS, film to digital, fire to fuel). My backpacking is pretty much limited to weekends, and one full-week per year (usually in the summer), with assorted canoe, caving, and rafting trips to round things out. I spend most of my time hiking the Allegheny Mountains (Pennsylvania and West Virginia) where there are more trails than you could walk in a lifetime, and conditions range from easy to strenuous.



Delivery: The package was delivered by Federal Express in a well-packed box; I like the fact that the Lantern was padded with packing paper (bio-degradable) rather than Styrofoam peanuts, shows some level of concern for the environment. The product itself is packaged in a cardboard display rather than hard-cased plastic, again a sign of environmental concern.
Appearance: Spenco Day HikersThese are the most unique looking insoles that I've seen to-date, it's obvious that a lot of thought went into the design of the footbeds, and you can see where the modifications have been made. The bottoms are coded in five different colors, and each color represents a different type of cushioning, a system they refer to as PolySorbShox (see side photos).
  • Taking it from the top is a grey base material, soft and flexible
  • Next is a black material, ridged, soft, and with air holes to allow air and moisture to pass through
  • Below that is a brown layer made of a hard, rigid material for form and support
  • Next are two green pads, somewhat firmer than the black layer, but still providing a cushioning for impact, both at the part of the foot next to the arch, and to the outside of the heel
  • Finally, there is a yellow pad on the inside of the heel, much less cushioning than the green pads, providing a firmer, though not rigid, support
  • The tops are covered with a wicking material to help remove excess moisture and, according to Spenco, to reduce hot spots and blisters. The green covering here is soft, and has a fabric-look, and also contains the Spenco Outdoor Adventure Series logo.
By the way, on the top of the package is a freebee ­ a key chain style 'biner. I like 'biners, they make it easy for me to attach things to my pack - thanks, Spenco!
Instructions: Spenco Day Hikers

No booklet is included, but hey, they're insoles after all; almost sufficient instructions are printed on the box. The directions read, "Remove existing insole (some brands of shoes glue the insole to the shoe, but careful removal will not damage the shoe). Insert the Spenco OAS Footbed into the shoe. Trim with scissors if necessary. Hand wash with warm water. Air dry."

For the most part these instructions were easy to follow, and I quickly replaced my old insoles with the new Day Hiker Footbeds. Fortunately, mine fit perfectly, I wear a US 8.5 (Euro 7.5) which falls in the middle of their range (US 8-9). Had trimming been necessary there is no pattern on the Day Hiker Footbeds to guide you, other brands I have used imprint a cutting guide to assure a perfect fit.

Expectations:

I spend most of my time hiking the Laurel Ridge area of Western Pennsylvania/West Virginia, where the terrain is rocky, and elevations are constantly changing. Most hiking shoes come with a minimal insole, offering little or no cushioning and support. By the end of even a short day hike (7-9 miles, 11-14.5 km) my feet are sore and ready for a soaking in a hot tub. I have spent many years (and dollars) looking for a good insole, in fact I've probably spent more money on insoles than on shoes. Most are made for sales people (standing around), runners, and other athletes who work out on flat, level, playing fields ­ hardly what I experience on hiking trips; so is it no wonder that most insoles just don't do much to help my feet feel better at the end of the day?

With all of the work that went into the design of the Spenco Day Hikers, I have great hopes on these being an entirely different breed of insole (even the name "footbed" makes them sound different). Along with the cushioning, I like the idea of them wicking away the moisture, though I am more skeptical about that than any other claim, after all they are on the bottoms of the feet, and moisture evaporates upward; my feet sweat profusely, and I usually end up changing my socks midway through a good summer hike, so I am looking forward to this feature.

First Use:

I was anxious to begin testing the footbeds so I immediately put them into my Merrell Low Hikers, two things I noticed immediately: they were very soft and comfortable (for the most part), but the arch was uncomfortably high. Upon inspection of the shoe and the insole I discovered that the arch in the footbeds is indeed higher than what was in the shoe originally. After a few days my feet became accustom to the higher arch.

I have been using the footbeds daily at work, and during my hikes at lunch - I happen to be lucky enough to work just a five minute walk from a hiking trail. Also, I work on the fourth floor of our building, and typically walk the stairs rather than taking the elevator. What I have discovered during this first week is that the Spenco Day Hikers are very comfortable, and my feet feel much better at the end of a day than usual. So far as the wicking feature, I haven't noticed any significant difference than before, though I am wearing normal cotton socks, not wicking hiking socks.

Test Plan:

Over the next four months I will be conducting several tests on low-impact day hikes. Spenco states that these are for Light Hikes / Trail Walking, but what, exactly, is a light hike? The only guidelines in their literature states: "1-Day trip carrying 0-25 lbs (11 kgs)." This is not very defining, so I am curious as to just how much "punishment" they can handle in a day hike. I lead introductory day hikes for "newbies," starting slow and building up; it is my intent to put the Spenco Day Hikers through the same paces.

The initial hike will be through a local park, the trail is 4.5 miles in length, easy terrain, moderately soft ground. From there the hikes will build in length, difficulty of terrain, and hardness of surface. The Laurel Ridge, where I do most of my hiking, is rocky, with the boulders which underly Pennsylvania lining much of the trails. This is where the capabilities of the Spenco Day Hikers will, in my opinion, be put to their most difficult tests, and the final hike (a 10-mile trek over rocky, constantly changing elevations) will separate a good insole from a fair one.



Read more reviews of Spenco gear
Read more gear reviews by Mike Lipay

Reviews > Footwear > Footbeds and Insoles > Spenco OAS Day Hiker > Mike Lipay > Initial Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson