BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Footwear > Trail Shoes > Merrell Waterpro Ultrasport > Arron Robinson > Field Report

Field Report - Merrell Waterpro Ultra-Sport shoes

Reviewer Info:[back to top]-- shot of Merrell Waterpros after 2 months --

Name: Arron Robinson
Age: 34
Gender: Male
Height: 5' 9.5" (1.77 m)
Weight: 230 lb (104.3 kg)
Email address: mouserar-at-gmail-dot-com
City, State, Country: Dallas, Georgia, USA
Date: 30 December 2005

Backpacking Background:  Camping and hiking since 11, I've been in a constant search for the perfect balance between usability, durability and weight. These days my camping is generally a mix of Boy Scout style crew camping, kayak or canoe camping or light to mid weight hiking. I generally carry 20-25 lb (9-11.3 kg) and sleep in a hammock system.

Product information:

Manufacturer:  Merrell
Specifications as Measured by Me:
Weight 16 oz (454 g) for the pair
Size Tested: 10.5 US - 10 UK - 44.5 EUR
Sole Type: Vibram® RinseMaster™
Other Features:
Mesh/Synthetic Leather Uppers

Micro Mesh Drainage Ports

Toe Protection

Dynamic Lacing System with Free Floating Heel
MSRP: $79.99 USD
URL:  http://www.merrell.com
Reviewer Info | Product Description | Field Conditions
Field Information | Test NotesImpressions After Field Testing 

Product Description:[back to top] 

The Merrell Waterpro Ultra-Sports are a lightweight multi-purpose outdoor shoe. It has many features that are specifically designed for use in water or wet conditions. They feature a mesh upper supported by synthetic leather for structure. Along the perimeter of the body of the shoe is a zig-zagging length of 1/4 inch (6 mm) webbing, which supports the laces and can be adjusted by a buckle at the heel of the shoe. The webbing floats freely through a series of channels in the "leather" supports, allowing for the laces to be adjusted for tension. The laces are quite thin, perhaps a little thicker than 1/16th of an inch (2 mm) which seem to be able to hold a knot quite well while wet.

Along with this interesting upper and lacing system is the Vibram® sole, which seems to have a slightly deeper profile than I have seen in other Merrell shoes in the past. A look at the foot bed while backlit shows that it is perforated with a grid of drainage holes which should allow the shoes to drain quickly.

Field Conditions:[back to top]

The Merrells were tested on a number of day hikes as well as two 4-day camping trips. While wearing the Merrells on these trips I wore polypro liners under wool/Lycra socks. The weather on these trips has been steadily dropping, providing a wide range in testing, with temperatures ranging from 70 F (21 C) to 25 F (-4 C) and precipitation consisting of a fair amount of rain on two of these outings. Morning dew provided a large amount of cold dampness on the other trips.

Field Information:[back to top]

-- Staining on heel --I wish to point out that autumn and early winter would not have been my first choices to test a shoe designed for water use, but surprisingly they have worked out well to this point. Some thought into the types of socks worn under them was needed, and it took me a bit of time to get used to the idea of mesh shoes in colder temperatures but while winds blow right through the body of the shoes and rain and dew soak them quickly, the design of the shoes allow for them to quickly dry out. The socks, helped by the heat of my feet, gradually do so as well. The shoes have not had any excessive wear or breakage.

The one thing that I have noticed is that there is what I would consider severe discoloration on the leather-like material. This was caused by dirty pant cuffs rubbing against the shoes. I have tried to clean these parts with various cleansers but nothing seems to take care of it. I am going to give Merrell a call and see if they have any suggestions, or if this is just the nature of the material.

Test Notes:[back to top]

The outings I have done so far have given me a good look at the shoes as far as general use goes. Below are my current findings:
  1. Comfort: This is where it all comes down. If your feet are not comfortable it will ruin a trip fast. Do the shoes stay comfortable when they are wet? Yes, they breathe very will and since the material is light, they do not get overly heavy. Do they change greatly in size? Not that I can tell. Do they drain well and quickly? Yes, they seem to, my socks stay squishy for a while, but they dry out rather well
  2. Adaptability: Is the foot bed comfortable for longer hiking? Yes. No problems yet. Do the shoes perform well as general hiking shoes? At this point in testing, that is all I have used them for. They work really well for this. Do they maintain footing underwater on varying terrain? I have not checked this out yet. An upcoming trip should provide insight into this. Do the stabilization systems keep my feet in place? Not been a problem up to this point. Does the lacing system allow for the shoes to be adjusted throughout the day as my feet change? Yes.
  3. Durability: Good shoes will generally be able to take some punishment. Shoes built with water in mind have to be able to take even more. Will these shoes last a season of hard use? So far, so good. Does the fabric crack and dry out? Not yet. Does the sole hold up? Yes, so far.
  4. Overall Design: OK, so I'm vain. Does the shoe look good, or will people assume that I'm wearing clown shoes? They look good and I have received a few comments on my cool shoes.  From the website, they look like a lot of other trail runners. Do these perform as advertised? So far. I am looking to do some in-depth water testing in the coming months.

Impressions After Field Testing:[back to top]

At this point in my testing, the shoes are holding up well and performing as expected. With a few small changes in my choice in socks and my expectations, they have proven to be very well suited for trail use, even in the cooler weather.

Aside from my one concern about the discoloration of the material I have no complaints.

Excitement:

  1. A very light shoe that is rugged and hold up to abuse.
  2. Toe guards! I always kick rocks
  3. They look good too!

Concerns:

  1. The synthetic leather has taken to discoloring. This makes the shoes look funky.

Thanks to Backpackgeartest.org and Merrell for the opportunity to share my experiences!



Read more reviews of Merrell gear
Read more gear reviews by arron robinson

Reviews > Footwear > Trail Shoes > Merrell Waterpro Ultrasport > Arron Robinson > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson