| |
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
|
|
Leatherman Charge Ti
Long Term Report
|
|
Name: |
Cora Shea |
|
Background:
I began backpacking in 1997. I love backpacking in spring
and winter snow more than anything, especially on skis. My pack
weight ranges from 15 to 90 lb (7 to 40 kg), and I vary sleeping in a
tarp, tent, quinzhee, snowcave, bolt-hole, bivy, people-pile, or
straight under the stars. I spend a lot of my time outdoors, and I
prioritize gear durability and functionality above weight.
|
|
Age: |
24 |
|
Gender: |
Female |
|
Height: |
5 ft 9 in (1.75 m) |
|
Weight: |
150 lb (70 kg) |
|
Email address: |
cahhmc at yahoo dot com |
|
Location: |
Los Angeles, California, USA |
|
Date: |
August 7, 2005 |
|
Basic Product Information
|
|
Manufacturer: Leatherman
|
Year of Manufacture: 2005
|
URL: http://www.leatherman.com/
|
|
Listed weight: 8.4 oz (238 g)
|
Weight as delivered:
8.4 oz (239 g) for main tool
|
Product: Charge Ti, $124 MSRP
|
| |
|
The Leatherman Charge Ti is a pliers-type multi-tool. It has two knives (serrated and straight), multiple bits, scissors, files (diamond and double cut bastard), saw, can opener, and (of course) pliers. It also has a variety of metals: titanium handles, 154 CM steel blades, and other steel throughout. It comes with eight bits (7 large, 1 eyeglass), a clip and lanyard ring, and a case.
This report covers long term use from April to August, 2005. For more product
information and items that can be reported on without field use (including the individual weights of all the included accessories), please see my
Initial Report. For a more in-depth description of field use, please see my Field Report.
|
|
Just like the period before my Field report, I've used the Charge Ti just about every day. This included ten more backcountry days, and a lot of use at work and around the house and in the office.
I backed off on the use of the Charge Ti in the backcountry during the test. This was somewhat because of its heaviness, but mostly because of its predilection toward rust (which I describe below). Even storing the Charge Ti in my Tupperware bowl for the night (which created some condensation from my food water) would create rust, which took me an hour or so to scrape off once home.
But, that maintenance aside, I still consider the Charge Ti to be a great tool,
especially in the ski season when I need most things on the tool. In the
summer, I consider the weight less worthwhile since all I really need is a
knife and a can opener. But, it is nice to have for the occasional odd use - I
enjoy having it in dry canyons for prying quicklink screws open (used for
anchors in canyons) and for sharpening the occasional bit of metal on my axe or
crampons after a particularly rocky day in the mountains (rock dulls and dents
like nothing else).
In fact, I found that what I least liked the Charge Ti for was basic summer backpacking. I appreciated the full extent of the Charge Ti in the off seasons when the pliers and bits came in handy.
However, the bits themselves still stayed the weakest piece of the tool. The
bits are so small that they slip a great deal, but they are better than nothing. But that is all that I can say for them since they are not really all that
useful. The Phillips bit in particular dented along the edges such that it now
slides and scrapes all around in a screw head when I try to use it. As I said
in my Field Report, I'd much rather give up the eyeglass screwdriver and the
larger standard screwdriver and then have room for a real bit adapter.
But in general, the Charge Ti definitely has stood up to a lot of use very well, and has certainly earned a spot in my work bag, where I use it every day.
|
|
Long Term Care and Maintenance:
Other than dealing with rust (which I describe below) and stropping and
sharpening the knife, the Charge Ti has essentially needed no maintenance. The
knives are very easy to clean all the way down to the hinges after cutting
messy things like avocado since the hinge is exposed and wipeable. The saw
teeth clean easily as well after cutting things like coconut husks and the odd
dead branch for firewood. The one exception was the file. The file, being
small-toothed, proved to be somewhat harder to clean, especially since I felt
washing it out with water would only rust it. But other than that, the Charge
Ti needed no maintenance.
As for long-term care, I would wipe down the Charge Ti with a dry cloth when it
got dirty, and oil the hinges (and wipe them out) when they got gritty. But I
did this a total of three times over six months of very dirty day-to-day use.
As for the rust below, when rust appeared I would file or scrape the rust off
with a dry brillo pad or steel wool, and then oil the surface.
Long Term Durability:
Overall, the Charge Ti is a very solid tool. I've torqued it, dropped it, used it for things it was perhaps not meant to be used for (such as prying metal lids, whittling aluminum, and other heavy-duty tasks) and generally abused it for six straight months. In general, I am very happy.
However, my two comments from my field report still hold. I have not really exposed the tool to water at all, and yet rust has formed nearly everywhere. Only with (what I consider to be) excessive cleaning can I keep the tool in presentable condition. The difficult to clean areas (such as the pliers hinge) rusted quite obviously. The pliers face rusted because it got stored for a few hours in the hinge, and I believe that caused the rust to spread. And, as far as I can tell, the small and light patches of rust on the tool edges in the last photo below were actually caused by my hand sweat, since those tools have not touched water at all:
 |
 |
 |
| Rust on the pliers hinge |
Rust on the pliers face |
Rust on the top tool edges |
I am not sure how to prevent or treat this sort of rust. It comes despite
careful care and attempted prevention, and appears on the knives especially
with vigor. (I don't have any knife-rust photos because I scour the knives
with equal vigor.) I've never had a knife that rusts this easily, and feel bad
that it has caused me to stop using it as much in the backcountry. Luckily, it
is such a great tool around an urban environment that I don't feel too
bad.
|
|
Overall, the Charge Ti has been a tool that has stood up to every use I could
throw at it. It sure is a bit hefty weight-wise (it tends to pull down the hem
of my pants a little when it's in my pocket) but its durability, sharpness, and
ease of use has surpassed all other pocket knives and tools I've used.
|
Likes
|
Dislikes
|
|
Ready for tough manual tasks
|
Heavy
|
|
Easy locking/unlocking mechanisms
|
Rust formed with minimal water exposure
|
|
Very sharp knives
|
Difficult to clean and oil
|
|
Read more reviews of Leatherman gear
Read more gear reviews by Cora Hussey
|