BackpackGearTest
Google
Web BackpackGearTest.org
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Packs > Internal and External Framed Backpacks > Gregory G-Pack 2005 > Gail Staisil > Field Report

 
Field Report:
Gregory G Pack
by Gail Staisil, Marquette, Michigan
November 19, 2005
 

 
Tester Information
Personal Data:
Name: Gail Staisil
Age: 53
Gender: Female
Height: 5'9" (1.75 m)
Weight: 132 lbs (60 kg)
Email:
woodswoman2001@yahoo.com
Location: Marquette, Michigan USA
Photo Album Website: http://community.webshots.com/user/isleroyalegirl 
Backpacking Background:
For the last 16 years, backpacking has become a passion. I am a four-season backpacker and an off-trail navigator. Although I do take yearly trips to the American West or Southwest, the majority of my trips are in Michigan and Canada. My pack weight varies considerably, but my base weight is under 20 lbs (9.1 kg). I am primarily a tarp camper, who averages over 50 nights a year backpacking in a huge variety of weather conditions, including relentless rain, wet snow and sub zero temps.

 
 Gregory G Pack--Description
Product Information:
Manufacturer: Gregory Mountain Products
Phone: 1.800.477.3420
Model: Gregory G Pack
Model Year: 2005
Size: Medium  2700 cu in  (48 L)
Manufacturer Weight: 2 lbs 12 oz  (1.2 kg)
Actual Weight: 2 lbs 12 oz (1.2 kg) 
Color: Bamboo Green
MSRP: $139 US 
 
Design/Features:
Usage guidelines: According to the hangtag that came with the G Pack, it is "designed for fast and light activities with sub 25 lb loads". On the same hang-tag, there is a selection graph of the different types of Gregory Packs. The G Pack is listed under the graphic entitled "weekend and light and fast", load capacity per this chart indicates a possible load level of 25 lb (11.3 kg)  to 35 lb (15.9 kg). I fully expect to try different load levels with this pack, to judge the upper limit for comfort.
 
Hydration: There is a pocket built in to the back of the pack to store a hydration system. Gregory has also provided a triangular fabric covered exit port on one side of the pack (the right side).  
 
Top Pocket: The top pocket is fully detachable. It closes by the means of a conventional zipper and the inside of the pocket has a loop with a hook to secure keys or another pertinent item. The top of the pocket is made out of the heavier 210 HT Nylon Fabric with the remainder of the hood utilizing silynylon (G70) for its structure. During my initial hike, I stored a quilted loft jacket and extra food items in the hood, it easily had room for more items.
 
Ice Axe Loops: Two ice axe loops are located in the traditional arrangement on the front bottom edge of the pack. I will most likely use these for trekking poles, but since ice climbing is popular in this area, they may at some point get utilized for their original purpose :) 
 
Main Compartment: This compartment is a top loader, it is approximately 23 in (58 cm) tall and is topped by an extension collar which adds another 5 in (13 cm). The base of the pack is in the neighborhood of 17 in (43 cm) wide and 7.25 in (18 cm) of depth.
 
Mesh Pockets (front and side): These are roomy mesh pockets with the front pocket measuring approximately 13 in (33 cm) at the base, 10.5 in (27 cm) at the top edge and 16.25 in (41 cm) in of height. The top edge is elasticized to possibly prevent loss of items. There are two side mesh pockets (one on each side). Each of these measures approximately 7 in (18 cm) at the base edge, 8.75 in (22 cm) at the top edge and 12.25 in (31 cm) for the height.
 
Mesh Zippered Pockets (on waist belt): I love these !! There are two mesh pockets, one on each side of the waist belt. They overlay the waist belt with each pocket being 3 in (8 cm) at the narrow end, expanding to 6.75 in (17 cm) at the middle and tapering back to 4.25 in (11 cm) at the side. They are approximately each 11.25 in 29 cm) long with a full length zipper on each pocket.
Technological Features:
Gullwing Waistbelt:  This is a very lightly padded waistbelt. On my initial hike, it was very comfortable. The padding extends almost completely around my waist with a light layer of clothing, but the additional 14 in (36 cm) of 1.5 in (4 cm) webbing will certainly be utilized, as I add more layers of clothing. I usually "buy" my waist belts sized to be padded almost around my entire waist so this is right on target for me.
 
Stealthlite Harness: Gregory also refers to this as a sport harness. I would qualify the harness as being shaped like a very soft "S", it was also very lightly padded and was comfortable during my initial hike. There is a daisy chain on top of each strap with 5 loop units. It is very easy to change the location of the sternum strap as indicated in my initial impressions below.
 
Wraptor Stabilizer: I can sum this up in two words: mechanical advantage. To clarify more, the 2 point strap system on the side of each pack connects the harness with the stabilizer. The stabilizer is a fabric covered "wing" that is reinforced with a rigid material. As I pull up on the strap, the stabilizer hugs the pack closely to my body and minimizes bounce. 
 
Exo Frame: This is a contoured, internal, rigid framesheet that allows torsional flexibility, but gives excellent support.
 
Chimney Ventilated Backpanel: The padded backpanel has a depression in the shape of an inverted "Y". This has been designed to circulate air and keep the body cool.
Materials:
Fabric G70: The main material of the pack is this light, silicone impregnated fabric. Other qualities include tear resistance.
 
Fabric 210 HT Nylon: This Nylon fabric is used in the high-stress areas of the pack to prevent ripping and tearing. The bottom of the pack, the back of the pack, and the top of the removable lid are some areas where this fabric is utilized
 

 
Field Testing Data
 
Field Location/Conditions:
During the field testing period of two months, I have used the Gregory G Pack for eleven days of backpacking and two days of day hiking.  The backpacking and  day hiking trips were to areas in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. They included a five day trip to the Rock River Canyon, Silver Creek Canyon and Laughing Whitefish River Area and a six day trip to Porcupine Mountains Wilderness State Park. Day hiking trips were made to sections of the North Country Trail in Marquette County. 
 
Conditions ranged from highly-deciduous old-growth forest to back-country river valleys, canyons and sandstone caves. Late-summer to late-fall weather varied from overcast and rainy to sunny conditions. Temperatures ranged from 40F (4C) to 85F (29C) with humidity in the normal range of  60 to 90 percent for those areas. All of the trips were at low altitude ranging from 600 ft (183m) to 2000 ft (610m), with a moderate amount of elevation changes - backcountry climbing and descending prevailed. 
 
Field Tests:
During the field testing period, I have put the Gregory G Pack through the grind. I have used it at the upper weight limits recommended by the manufacturer (35 lb/15.9 kg) and I have found that it held up nicely and it was very comfortable to wear. Both of my backpacking trips with the pack were of the mid-length variety (a five-day trip and a six-day trip). When I had received the pack, I wondered if I would be able to pull-off a multi-day trip with it. I initially thought that maybe it would suffice for an overnighter or two-night outing, but most of the trips on my calendar were much longer in length. The Gregory G's capacity is 2700 cu in (48 L), this is far smaller than any pack I have ever used for a lengthy trip. In fact, I normally take a 4800 cu in (79 L) pack for similar adventures. I set myself up to the challenge of seeing if I could use the pack for these longer trips. Would I have to scrap some of the gear that I normally take with me? 

 Trip 1 - Rock River Canyon (5 day) - September

This trip had its own set of challenges. I not only had to pack five days of gear but I also needed to carry a rock helmet as I would be exploring backcountry caves - would I be able to carry that much gear in a lightweight pack and be comfortable? I wanted to find out if it was possible. The weather forecast looked good. September is one of those marginal clime months in Michigan when anything could happen - even nights below freezing were possible.

Would the pack accommodate all my gear? My style of packing involves using silynylon stuff sacks for all of my gear. They insure water tightness plus the slipperiness of the sacks makes it easy to push smaller sacks into tight spaces of the pack without wasting any space. I decided to carry my light-weight hammock in combination with a silnylon tarp for this trip. The only other bulky item that would take up room inside the pack would be my sleeping bag and a light insulated jacket and fleece pants. I brought my 25F (-4C) down bag to insure warmth at night, because I would be sleeping off the ground and subject to cooler temps. And the food of course, there was lots of it with five days of regular rations plus extra meals for back-up. I stowed the food inside the pack in two separate silynylon stuff sacks. 

The top lid pocket of the pack held my rain gear, sun hat, light gloves, book, more snacks, toiletries and the like. The lid pocket has a two pull-tab zipper arrangement so that the contents are accessible from either side. I would later find this to be a handy feature.

I slipped a three-quarter length closed-cell pad into the center air-mesh pocket on the outside of the pack and lashed my rock helmet on the outside of that. The rock helmet would of fit in that pocket itself, but I decided to put the pad in there instead. There aren't any attachment straps across the back of the pack where I could carry a sleeping pad otherwise. I didn't have any room to stow the pad inside the pack but that would certainly be a possibility if I had been utilizing the pack for a shorter trip with less cargo. Two standard one-quart (liter) water bottles were stowed in the side mesh pockets. The pack does have a hydration sleeve inside, however I chose to use the exterior aforementioned pockets instead.

The mesh waist belt pockets held my usual array of bug-repellant, sunscreen, lip balm, snack bar, gum, and sunglass case. Although this may seem like a lot, I find the pockets to be invaluable.  I normally would have to either attach a floating "rib" pocket to the front of my other packs to make items accessible, or stop and take my pack off to reach items that were stowed in a top pocket. I have easy access to all of these items and I hardly notice the light layer of bulk on top of the waistbelt, it doesn't interfere with my stride or get in my way. I love these pockets! They are so convenient and I no longer have to attach a bulky "rib" pocket in front of my waist that once hindered my movement.

Overall, the food stores were the heaviest part of my load but I started the trip complete with 2 quarts (liters) of water at 34 lb (15.4 kg). The website chart indicated the extreme end of a load limit for the Gregory G at 35 lb (15.9 kg). I was happy to find that I didn't need to sacrifice any gear for this trip. Everything fit nicely - I have to admit that there wasn't any "extra" room, but it was a good test for the material and the seams especially.

One of my initial concerns with the packs was the narrow and thinner-than-most harness and waistbelt. I was pleasantly surprised to find that both of these lightly padded features were still comfortable with a heavy load throughout each day. During this trip I wore a Supplex long sleeve shirt but when it got too hot, I wore a long-waisted sport top. The shoulder harness was very comfortable against the bare skin of my shoulders.

The weather for this trip was unusually warm. In fact in was in the 80F ( 27C) range for the first few days. Being rather humid as well, I was impressed with the air flow that I experienced with the Chimney-Ventilated Backpanel. While my back got a little hot, it was mostly comfortable and I didn't experience much dampness on my shirt when I took the pack off at rest times.

In preparation for any trip, I usually attach a map pocket to the side adjustor straps of a backpack. Most of my trips are off-trail and I need to have my USGS Maps handy for navigation purposes. The compression straps on the sides of the Gregory G do not have a buckle and clip opening like many packs but have an adjustment feature or slider. I tried to move the strap completely out of the slider so that I could thread my map holder through the webbing. I could not seem to pull the webbing through the slider. I tried numerous times, but it seemed to get hung up on the hardware. Finally in frustration, I decided to attach cordage to the loops on the map holder and tie them on with a simple bow-line knot. I have since worked with the webbing more, and they just needed a bit of flexing to make them more pliable. I can now pull them through the slider and slip the loops of my map case through the webbing.

This was my first bushwhack adventure with the G Pack, so I wondered if the fabric and mesh netting would hold up to the abuse of such travel. In addition, there would be much contact with backcountry sandstone caves formations. Although the fabric and netting picked up a fair amount of sandstone debris, it was easy to brush off for the most part. At the end of the trip, I only needed to take a damp rag to wipe off the rest of the dirt. There was no damage to either the G70 fabric or the mesh netting.

I did notice at higher load levels that the waistbelt has a bit of a slippage issue, I had to re-tighten it several times during the first few days of the trip. However, when the load was decreased by several pounds due to declining food stores, it no longer became a necessity. It is also harder to adjust the Wraptor Stabilizer when the load level is at maximum. I do like the mechanical advantage of this system though, as pulling up on the strap is much easier to facilitate than a downward motion that is commonly used on many packs. The stabilizer "hugs" close to my body and really keeps the pack from unnecessary movement. I can really appreciate the saving of energy by not having to expend extra energy to balance the pack.

Trip 2 - Porcupine Mountains Wilderness (6 days) - October

This was a "different" type of backpacking trip than I normally take. Although it was a backpacking trip in cooler conditions, I would be staying in different back-country rustic cabins with bunks each night. Because I didn't need to carry any sort of shelter, an insulated pad or heavy insulated gear, I was able to fit all of my supplies for the six days in the Gregory G Pack. I again started the trip with a maximum load level of nearly 35 lb (15.9 kg). I quickly eliminated 2 lbs (0.9 kg) of water as there was abundant water everywhere on this trip, so it wasn't necessary to carry the normal amount of 4 lb (1.8 kg).

Like most packs, the comfort level was directly related to how I arranged my belongings in the pack. I once again brought my 25F (-4C)  down bag on this trip. Even though we had a wood-burning stove in our cabin each night, I didn't know how often we would tend it and I wanted to be sure that I would be warm throughout the night. The vast majority of my pack weight was food stores. I most likely had close to 15 lb (6.8 kg) in food due to additional desserts and the like. I also decided to take my Trangia alcohol stove and necessary fuel which is heavier/bulkier than my normal Esbit stove and Esbit fuel for a similar trip. I packed the food low in the bag next to my back and filled in the outside areas with lighter belongings such as the down bag. This seemed to work very well with this pack as it stayed close to my back and I experienced little to no shifting of the pack. This was especially important when I had to don my sandals to wade the river a few times during the journey. It also was a plus when crossing some of the old several-feet-high, elevated but shaky boardwalks.

Since I wasn't carrying a sleeping pad, I decided to use the center back mesh pocket to stow my water sandals and a small ground cloth that I had brought along to sit on during  trail breaks. I carried the majority of my snacks in the top lid so I didn't need to get into the main body of the pack during these breaks.

Once again, I stowed my water bottles in the side mesh pockets. The diagonal compression straps are somewhat of a nuisance as I can't get the items out of the side mesh pockets without loosening the straps. However, the combination of the elastic-edged mesh side pockets and the compression straps makes the possibility of losing gear almost impossible. This is a perk when bushwhacking through thick vegetation. The compression straps would also be useful for stabilizing a smaller load in the pack.

Day Trips - North Country Trail - October 18 and October 22

During the month of October, I took two day hikes to explore the outstanding fall color. My day trips took me to parts of the North Country Trail. The trail varies with rocky outcroppings, river-side views, old-growth forest and a fair share of ascents and descents. Both of my day hiking trips were in typical 50F(10C) to 60F(16C) fall temperatures. Distances for the trips were approximately 8 mi (13K) and 6 mi (10K). I packed the G Pack with additional layers of clothing, a small tarp, rain gear, lunch, snacks, emergency supplies, maps, camera, and the usual small items that total around 15 lb (6.8 kg) including water. I really didn't need to utilize the top pocket, but left it in place anyway. As the day trips progressed, I decided to stow a few items - my gloves and my hat. I thought about taking the pack off my body to stow those items in the back mesh pocket, but instead I decided to reach over my shoulder to see if I could open the top lid pocket. It was easy to open the double pull-tab zipper and I quickly stowed those items and pulled the zipper shut. It was a neat maneuver, and probably best accomplished when the top lid is not overstuffed with contents. Using the G Pack with a lighter load is simply fun, I sometimes forgot that I was even wearing a pack.

 

Overall Thoughts and Future Testing

As stated previously, I initially had serious doubts whether I could use the Gregory G for longer trips. I am now totally impressed with its capabilities for a mid- range trip in the warmer months of the year. To discover that I don't need a heavier, larger pack to facilitate these trips is a wonderful feeling. It not only accommodated the load well, but was also extremely comfortable.

As I progress into the long term stage of testing the Gregory G Pack, I will focus on its capabilities as a day pack. At this point in the season in these northern climes, the gear required for winter trips is just too vast and bulky to fit in to the Gregory G, even for an overnighter. I will instead concentrate on taking it on more day excursions in combination with both xc skiing and snowshoeing. I will be examining the long-term durability and the water-resistance of the pack when exposed to wet snow and more.

Likes:

      • Waistbelt pockets are invaluable
      • Versatile - day pack and multi-day pack capabilities 
      • Pack stays close to body when doing awkward moves
      • Very comfortable pack
Dislikes: 
      • Diagonal compression straps restrict accessibility of items in side mesh pockets
      • Initially difficult to move webbing through sliders without "working" the webbing to make it pliable
      • Lack of attachment straps to secure a sleeping pad or other large item to center of back 
  

Tester Remarks 

 
Thanks to Gregory Mountain Products and BGT for this great opportunity to test such an outstanding product.


Read more reviews of Gregory gear
Read more gear reviews by Gail Staisil

Reviews > Packs > Internal and External Framed Backpacks > Gregory G-Pack 2005 > Gail Staisil > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson