BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Rain Gear > Gaiters > OR Rocky Mountain High Packcloth Gaiters > Graham Blamey > Field Report

Header F
 
Personal Information
  • Name : Graham Blamey
  • Age : 60
  • Height : 1.82 m (6' 0")
  • Weight : 75 kg (165 lb)
  • Email : gg@higray.fsnet.co.uk
  • County : Essex
  • Country : UK
  • Date : 23 March 2004
Additional product related information
  • Boot/shoe size : UK 10, US 10.5, EU 44
  • Inside leg measurement : 84 cm (33")
Backpacking background

I first went camping at about age five and have been camping, on and off, ever since.  I started serious walking about 21 years ago and backpacking a few years later.  I have backpacked, with my wife Ginny, mainly in Europe and the UK. We have spent three weeks of each year for the last six years, backpacking on variations of the GR11, a long-distance, high-level route that follows the spine of the French/Spanish Pyrenees.  We spend at least one day a week on long day-walks and take a number of three- to four-day backpacking trips throughout the year.  We also take part in several night and weekend orienteering events.  Our backpacking style, although essentially traditional (mid-weight backpacks, Therm-a-Rests, tent etc.) is getting increasingly lighter as we explore the possibilities brought about by new materials and designs.
Product  Information
Manufacturer : Outdoor Research
  • Manufacturer's website : www.orgear.com
  • Sizes : S / M / L / XL
  • Weight : 199 g (7 oz) per pair (not stated what size)
  • Material : 400 denier Nylon Packcloth
  • Colours : Black, Black / Purple, Blue / Black
  • MSRP : $ 35.00
The following is taken from the manufacturer's website:
  • Strap and buckle top closure
  • 50 mm (1") wide Velcro front closure
  • Packcloth leg section
  • Grommeted instep lace anchor
  • Hook and snap
  • Elastic bottom edge
  • Nylon instep lace
  • Coated packcloth foot section
There are a couple of illustrations of the gaiter and quite a lot of additional information on the manufacturer's website.
Product as received
  • Size : Large
  • Weight : 190 g (6.7 oz)
  • Height : (Measured vertically along rear of gaiter) 46.5 cm (18.25")
  • Circumference : (Measured around top of gaiter) 44 cm (17.3")
  • Colour : Black
For a more detailed description and my Initial impressions, see my: INITIAL REPORT

FIELD REPORT

For the past two months, I've worn these gaiters on almost every walk I've taken.  Weather during this period has been wet, rainy, cold and occasionally frosty.  For about a week during this period, we had a light snowfall, varying between 50 mm - 150 mm (2" - 6") in different parts of the UK.  (I had about 100 mm (4") which in some places where it drifted on field edges, was 300 mm (12") deep).

I've worn the gaiters with two types of footwear.  My boots, which are Karrimor KSB, fabric and leather, and GoreTex lined, and my Merrell Chameleon trail-shoes which are also fabric and leather but do not have a waterproof lining.
In terms of fit, not unexpectedly, the gaiters work best on my boots.  There seems to be just the right amount of material in the lower part of the  gaiters that fits over and around the boot, to efficiently Gaiters and bootscover the important parts of my boot without there being any excess which would 'pouch' and leave gaps in the fitting.  The leg portion, when wearing just one pair of stretch trail-pants, is quite snug-fitting.  These gaiters are slimmer in the leg than most other similar ones I've tried but not uncomfortably so and, were they any wider in this section, for me, this would be wasted material.  The length of the gaiters is spot-on for me, when worn with my boots.  They terminate just below the back of my knee, completely covering my calf muscle and when I tighten the top strap, because it's wide and not like a cord, I can hardly feel any pressure from it.  This is a very comfortable top fixing in my opinion.   I've not noticed any times when the gaiters seem to be sliding down, as most of the time, most lower leg movements seem to be within the scope of the material available (so to speak) and they don't seem to be stretched.  I have no problem pulling the front of the gaiters forward to hook it in the bottom lace of my boots and I think that if I had a pair of boots that laced to further down the toe-cap than my current ones, the elastic around the bottom edge, would allow the gaiter to fit these too (see photo above which illustrates some of the points made here).

When I've worn the gaiters with my Merrell Chameleon trail shoes, they've been just as comfortable but the fit is slightly different.  Because of the different style of lacing, the front of the gaiGaiters and Merrellsters can't hook as far forward.  There also isn't the same amount of ankle cuff as with the boots, to fill the lower part of the gaiters and the overall appearance is slightly crumpled or baggy, as if they are a little too big (see photo right).
When I originally sized the gaiters by tying the instep cord, I sized them for my boots.  As I've worn them mostly with these and the knots I tied are now more or less permanent, I've not tried to undo and retie the cord.  It might be possible to adjust the cord to get a better fit with the Merrell's but I'm not that fussed because, as I said earlier they're just as comfortable, they just don't look as sleek :)

Although wearing gaiters with non-waterproof footwear might at first seem puzzling, there is a point.  Mud and water that's not deep enough to swamp the shoes can be splashed or carried up (see photo) and washing a muddy pair of gaiters at the end of each day is a lot easier and more practical than a daily washing of trousers.

In terms of wear and tear they are holding up extremely well.  The instep cord which I was concerned about initially is still in one piece, the Velcro fastening down the front grips well and hasn't once come undone or shown any gaps, the front hook has never come off the lacing and the strap around the top of the gaiter has never come undone.  They are really easy to clean after a day's muddy walking, just a slosh down with cold water with perhaps a little rubbing or scrubbing in places where any mud has dried.  The gaiters dry very quickly I've found, shedding the bulk of the water with a vigorous shake.  So far, any mud seems to come off completely and I've not noticed anywhere where it's starting to clog the fabric.

On all the occasions I've worn them, in rain, mud and ankle-deep snow, they've proved to be fully waterproof, especially the lower, proofed section, but even the upper un-proofed leg area hasn't shown any sign of water penetration.  When wearing boots, I've sloshed through water and waded through snow with abandon, in the interests of research.  I've pushed through thorny scrub on a number of occasions and although I've heard and felt the material catch, I've not yet noticed any sustained damage.  I haven't noticed any moisture inside the gaiters from condensation either, even when walking strenuously on some of the fast, shorter, training walks I do sometimes when, inevitably, the part of my legs encased in the gaiters starts to feel much warmer.

Putting the gaiters on and taking them off couldn't be easier.  I hook the instep cord under my boot, wrap the gaiter around my leg and fasten the snap at the front.  It's then simple to hook the front hook to my bottom lace and fasten the Velcro up the front.  Lastly (and this is sometimes a tad fiddly with cold hands) I thread the top strap end through the buckle clip, adjust the tightness and fold the buckle cam over to hold it in place.  Removal is more or less a reversal of this process.  I was at first irritated by the amount of the top strap that was flapping loose once the buckle had been tightened but it doesn't get in the way and I now tend to disregard it. 

Test conditions over the next few months, as we drift out of winter and into spring will probably continue wet, but hopefully will start to get warmer.  I'll probably be wearing these gaiters at least until the beginning of May, but I have no problem with carrying them in my pack on a 'just in case' basis as they're light and take up little space.

Overall, I'm finding these gaiters a pleasure to wear.  I'm quite happy wearing gaiters if the weather conditions dictate, and these are more comfortable than any others I use and so far, are performing well.  I like to have kit that does what it's supposed to and these fit that bill.
Now, if only they did them for dogs :
ALFIE

My thanks to BackpackGearTest and Outdoor Research for the opportunity to test this product.



Read more reviews of Outdoor Research gear
Read more gear reviews by Graham Blamey

Reviews > Rain Gear > Gaiters > OR Rocky Mountain High Packcloth Gaiters > Graham Blamey > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson