| |
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
|
Initial Report - GoLite Whim Pants
by Mike Lipay - June 1, 2006
| Description |
| Date Arrived | April 20, 2006 |
 Image from GoLite |
| Manufacturer | GoLite |
| Year of Manufacturer | 2006 |
| Website | www.GoLite.com |
| MSRP | $70.00 USD |
| Warranty | GoLite stands behind its products. We will replace any gear with a manufacturing defect for the lifetime of the product, free of charge. If a product fails to perform as advertised, return it for a repair, replacement or refund. Damage due to wear and tear will be repaired at a reasonable charge to the user. |
Mfgr. Specs from website |
Model: Whim Pants
Size: Large
Weight: 4 oz (110 g) |
Personal measurements |
Model: Whim Pants
Size: Large
Weight: 3.9 oz (111 g)
|
| Personal Information |
| Name | Mike Lipay |
| Age | 51 |
| Gender | Male |
| Height | 5 ft 8 in / 173 cm |
| Weight | 185 lbs / 83.9 kg |
| Email | hiking AT westernpa DOT us |
| City, State | Plum, Pennsylvania |
| Background | I've been hiking and backpacking since the '60s. I enjoy hiking solo, with my kids, or with the Keystone Trails Association's group and trail-care trips. I have taught LNT skills, wilderness survival, and outdoor first-aid. I am no ultra-light backpacker (my pack typically weighs 29-40 lb (13-18 kg) loaded), although I am always looking for ways to cut down on the weight. I'm a low-techie, preferring a hiking staff to trekking poles, compass to GPS, fire to fuel; but I am open to new products when there is a distinct advantage over more traditional "technology". |
| Delivery | April 20, 2006 |
| Appearance, Features, and Usage |
From GoLite's website, and the product hangtag:
DESCRIPTION - The Whim Pants are a 4 oz ultra-lite wonder that offers wind and water protection plus great durability for the weight! Constructed of WispUltra, a 98% polyester/2% carbon fabric with a Super-DWR coating, these wind pants are highly breathable and pack small into the back pocket so there's never a reason to leave them behind.
Based on GoLite's description, both on their website and hangtag, I was under the impression that the Whim pants were being sold as emergency rain wear. As I have discovered since, the GoLite Whim pants are categorized as "Ultra-lite Wind Shells," for "insurance" against light rain, wind, and quick temperature drops. I will attempt to test the Whims under these conditions.
KEY FEATURES - WispUltra 98% polyester/2% carbon fabric with Super-DWR finish Ultra-lite, wind resistant, water repellent, breathable, packs small Self-stowing Flat braided drawcord at the waist.
COLORS - Night
AVAILABLE SIZES - (Unisex sizing) X-Small, Small, Medium, Large, X-Large, XX-Large |
| Field Conditions |
The majority of my hiking is in the Laurel Highlands area of the Allegheny Mountains. Typical terrain varies from soft, pine-covered trails to hard, rocky trails. Elevation ranges from 1200-3230 ft (366-985 m). Temperatures during the test period typically range from 50°F lows (13.8°C) to 83°F (28°C) highs, with fewer than 10 days with temps above 90°F (32°C). The area typically has 11 days of measurable rain per month, averaging slightly less than 4 in (10 cm) monthly.
|
| Personal Observations |
The first thing I noticed about the GoLite Whim pants is the weight, even though the specs state 4 oz (113 g) I wasn't prepared for the light weight - I have stuff sacks that feel heavier! The second thing that became apparent was a small pocket located inside the pants on the right rear. The pocket measures 5-1/2 in (14 cm) square, and is just large enough for my wallet - a nice feature that doubles as a built-in stuff sack.
What my hiking partner noticed first was the large, white, GoLite logo on the front right. While I didn't mind it, his feeling was that it was like a billboard against the black material of the pants.
The outside appearance is a satin-black appearance, while the inside reminds me of shiny black-plastic bags.
|
| First Use: |
The arrival of the GoLite Whim pants was indeed fortunate, coming the day before a planned outing. This was one of those trips that makes me wonder why there is a weather forecasting department, predictions were for light drizzle with the possibility of thundershowers. The morning started off with temps at 48° F (8° C), but quickly warmed up to 62° F (17° C) where it remained for the day. The rain started around 8 A.M. and lasted for the entire day, coming down hard and fast, turning the trails into small streams.
As soon as the rain started I pulled my GoLite Whim pants out of my back pocket (they really do fit easily). Putting them on wasn't as easy as I had hoped, the opening in the pants leg wasn't large enough to fit over my hiking boots, requiring the removal of my boots. I must say, though, that they fit well over my hiking pants, not causing the legs to ride up, or making it feel as if I had two pairs of pants on.
Once I had the Whims on I was ready for the testing to begin. Sure enough, I had plenty of opportunity to see how well they would work as it rained the entire day. I was impressed at how dry I felt, with two layers of pants on I wasn't feeling a heat or moisture build up. By the end of the day my GORE-TEX rain jacket was letting a little moisture through, but my hiking pants were nicely dry.
Taking the Whim pants off was similar to getting them on: untying the drawcord was easy, but I had to remove my shoes in order to take the pants off. This is the most annoying feature, with the heavy rain my socks and shoes became wet during the changeover.
|
| Test Plan: |
While I might not wear them at every hiking trip, I would always carry the GoLite Whims with me as they are intended to be used - in case a quick storm rears its ugly thunder-clouded head. The weather in the Allegheny's is difficult to predict, or so the meteorologists are always saying, a freak storm catching you off guard is not an uncommon occurrence here, and having a good pair of water repellant pants at hand is a necessity. Breath-ability is also a must, when the storms crop up on a hot June or July day I can get just as wet from sweating as I would have from the rain. My current emergency pair are anything but light-weight, easy to pack, and breathable; replacing them would be more than a Whim, it would be a dream-come-true!
Additionally, having a pair of these in my pocket at a ballgame would be a fantastic way to be prepared for when a shower interrupts the viewing (but not the game). I have been caught in more than my fair share of baseball games when a storm comes along, and our stadium doesn't have many places where you can get out of the rain.
EVALUTIONS
What I would be most concerned with, and would pay the most attention to, is:
- QUALITY: Tightness of the seams, without bunching. Water repellency at the seams -- do the seams need to be sealed?
- FIT: In addition to just plain fitting, how will they fit as an outer layer? I certainly don't want to get undressed just to change pants when a shower strikes. Also, will the legs go on over a pair of hiking boots, or will I need to remove the boots before I put on the GoLite Whims? Again, this is in the event of an emergency storm where every moment counts.
- COMFORT: When worn as regular hiking pants, on days when it is raining before I even start out, how does the nylon feel against the skin -- does it stick? When worn on the outside, over another pair of pants in an emergency situation, will they wind up being to hot? Too tight? Another thing that concerns me, with regards to comfort, is that they are only available in black -- will they be too hot in the summer, especially with the sun beating down?
- ENDURANCE: I know the GoLite Whims are made to be packed (even in a back pocket), but how well will they hold up to being crumpled and removed? Will it affect the water-resistance? Are they capable of holding up to jagged bushes, and still retain their water-shedding abilities? Will the drawcord at the waist begin to fray before the end of the test period? I've found that drawcords have the tendency to break, or to not hold their place during heavy exercise (such as climbing a steep trail).
|
I would like to take this opportunity to thank both GoLite and BackpackGearTest.org for the chance to test the Whim pants.
Read more reviews of GoLite gear
Read more gear reviews by Mike Lipay
|