BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Rain Gear > Jackets and Pants > Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket > Pat McNeilly > Test Report by Patrick McNeilly

Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket
Most recent update: March 8, 2007

Initial Report


Review Date: October 24, 2006

Name: Pat McNeilly
Age: 44
Gender: Male
Height: 5’ 8” (1.7 m)
Weight: 155 lb (70 kg)
eVENT Cruiser JacketEmail address: patrick dot mcneilly at hhs dot gov
City, State, Country: Gaithersburg, MD, USA

Backpacking Background:
I have been hiking for at least 20 years but backpacking for only the last four years.  Most of my backpacking is done as overnight trips and occasional weekend and weeklong trips.  My typical pack weight is approximately 18 to 20 lb (8 to 9 kg) before food or water.  Most of my backpacking is the three season variety in the mountains of Maryland, Virginia, and West Virginia.  In addition to backpacking, I also fish, hunt, and have been involved in disaster relief.  As a result, some of my backpacking equipment gets use in a number of different venues.

Product Information:

Product: eVENT Cruiser Jacket
Size: Medium
Manufacturer: Integral Designs
Year of Manufacture: 2006
Color: Green
Jacket Weight: 10.8 oz (306 g) [measured];  11.5 oz (326 g) [listed]
Stuff Sack Weight: 0.4 oz (11 g) [measured]; no listed weight
URL:  http://www.integraldesigns.com
MSRP: $200 US

Product Description:
Jacket in stuff sackThe Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket is a light weight waterproof jacket constructed using a breathable 40 denier nylon eVENT fabric.  The jacket is a solid green color with a 1.75 in (4 cm) high triangular Integral Designs logo and a 1.5 in (3 cm) eVENT logo attached to the left chest region of the jacket.  The jacket has a 25.5 in (65 cm) black waterproof zipper with a 3 in (8 cm) zipper pull attached bearing the Integral Designs name.  There is also a 1.75 in (4 cm) roughly triangular patch of fabric at the top of the main zipper to protect the chin from contacting the zipper.  The jacket also has a stand-up collar which measures 3 in (8 cm) in the front and 3.5 in (9 cm) in the back.  The hem of the jacket is curved and the front measures 23 in (58 cm) from the base of the collar to the bottom of the jacket, while the back measures 29 in (74 cm).  Lycra bands rim the wrist openings and the bottom hem of the garment.  The product utilizes raglan sleeves with shaped elbows.  The jacket has two front pockets with 7 in (18 cm) zippers located on the side seams.  The pockets measure approximately 10 in (25 cm) x 10 in (25 cm).  All seams on the garment are taped.

Product Review:
The Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket arrived in a padded shipping envelope.  Inside, the garment was stored in a clear sil-nylon stuff sack which measures 9 in (23 cm) x 9 in (23 cm) and has a 9 in (23 cm) zipper and a 1 in (2 cm) hang loop.  Located inside the stuff sack were two cards, one describing the Cruiser Jacket and another describing the eVENT fabric.  The product appeared as it did on the manufacturer’s website.

Loose threads close-upOverall, the product appears to be very well made.  The outside of the jacket has a soft feeling somewhat like a cotton polyester blend.  The inside is a silver color and has a rather slick feeling to it.  If examined closely, I noticed that the interior of the eVENT fabric has a very fine ribbed structure.  The stitching appears to be very tight and uniform.  I do not notice any problems with the taping of the seams.  The only thing of any concern that I noticed is that a few of the stitches around the lycra hem appear to be loose (I am being very picky here). 

The jacket fits very well and I can easily layer a fleece underneath without feeling too tight around the arms or chest.  The manufacturer’s information indicated that the back is 3 in (8 cm) longer than the front.  However, I measured a 6 in (15 cm) difference between the front and the back.  When the jacket is zippered the lycra band at the hem pulls the bottom in against the body which also pulls the hem in the back up slightly and effectively creates a roughly 3 in (8 cm) difference between front and back.

The jacket has a raglan sleeve design which allows for no seams in the shoulder region and no apparent binding when moving the arms.  The sleeves are slightly long for me but this allows me to reach up without having to expose my wrists.  The lycra bands at the wrists also provide just enough snugness to keep the sleeves in place but not too tight around the wrist. 

The waterproof zipper runs the length of the jacket’s front and is somewhat stiff.  This is particularly true as I pull the zipper to the very top near my chin.  I find it rather difficult to get the zipper the last 2-3 in (5-8cm).

The collar is stiff enough to stand up on its own but no too stiff to be an annoyance.  The pockets seem to be large enough for holding fairly large items.

There are two tags on the inside of the jacket at the collar with differing cleaning instructions.  The first is from Integral Designs which indicates that the jacket should be hand washed with mild soap. The other tag appears to be from the eVENT fabric manufacturer which indicates that the fabric should be machine washed with liquid detergent.  This leaves some ambiguity on what the proper cleaning method is. 

Test Plan:
I plan to use the eVENT Cruiser Jacket as my primary raingear on any backpacking to hiking trip I take during the course of the test period.

I plan to evaluate the following:

Size/Fit: 
How is the Cruiser Jacket in terms of layering?  How bulky an item will fit underneath?
How easy is the jacket to put on when wearing various types of materials underneath (e.g., fleece, wool, polyester)?
Do the sleeves allow the wearer to reach overhead without binding? 
Do the lycra cuffs provide adequate closure, or do they allow water to run in (particularly when reaching up)? 
Does the collar close tightly against the chin and is it comfortable? 

Waterproofness/Breathablity: 
How well does the jacket keep out water in various rain conditions. 
Does it handle light rain but not a downpour? 
Is the jacket breathable?  Does hiking in the jacket cause excess sweating?
Does the jacket work well as a wind shell in the absence of rain?

Features:
Does the waterproof zipper operate smoothly?  Does it loosen up over time?
Does the collar provide adequate protection from water running off a hat or the back of my head? 
Are the pockets large enough to hold items such as gloves?
Can I access the pockets with gloves on?

Durability/Care: 
Does that 40 denier fabric need special care. 
Can the fabric hold up to abrasion?  Are there special wear areas, such as the elbows or the zipper? 
How easy is the Cruiser Jacket to clean? 
Is there a difference between machine washing and hand washing for this product?
Will the loose threads on the lycra hem come loose?

This ends my initial report of the Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket.

Field Report

Review Date: January 10, 2007

Field Information:
I have been using the Cruiser Jacket on a variety of trips.  This includes everything from weekend trips to driving around town and shopping in the jacket.

I have worn the jacket on overnight trips in Maryland and northern New Jersey where temperatures ranged from 18-50 F (-8-10 C).   I did not run into any rain on these trips but did encounter some windy conditions along with the cool temperatures.  I have also worn the jacket on a number of day hikes throughout central Maryland and northern Virginia.  Temperatures on these hikes ranged from 25-60 F (-4-16 C) with varying wind conditions.   On a few of these day hikes, I did run into mild to moderate rain.  Elevations for all these trips ranged from 300-1500 ft (91-457 m).

Product Review:
I have been using the Cruiser Jacket for approximately ten weeks and I find that the jacket’s fit is very comfortable and I have received a number of complements on the looks of the jacket (one from another outdoor clothing manufacturer’s representative).  The garment is very well made and I have not noticed any problems with wear of the fabric or loose seams (other than what was mentioned in my initial report).  As I mentioned above, the jacket can easily fit over a fleece and I can even add a third insulating layer but at that point I feel some bonding under the arms and around the chest.   I am able to fit my down vest under the Cruiser Jacket but if I wear another insulating layer under the vest I seem to get a little too much compression of the down.  The inside of the jacket has a somewhat slick feeling and I find that I can easily slide the jacket on over most any fabric without any problem.

The sleeves allow for adequate movement and stay in place when reaching over my head.  Although the sleeves are slightly long for me, the lycra cuffs tend to fold inward slightly.  This allows for the extra fabric which is folded inward to provide complete coverage of the arm and wrist when reaching out.

The water resistant zipper remains somewhat stiff and I have noticed that I occasionally have a problem getting the zipper started.  I find that I have to be particularly careful when aligning the ends of the zipper.  If not aligned properly the jacket won’t close.  If I reposition the ends of the zipper I am able to zip the jacket properly.  I have not had any problems with water getting through the zipper as of yet.

Water droplets on fabricI have not worn the Cruiser Jacket in any downpours but have been out in some light and moderate showers.  One thing I will note is that water actually beads up on the jacket and runs off.  If I step into a dry place, I can literally shake the water off the jacket.  The jacket provides ample coverage but the rear bottom hem tends to be pulled upward and exposes a bit more to the elements. I have not had any major problem with this up to this point.  I also note that when I wear any kind of pack with a hip belt the rear hem does not ride up as much and this becomes less of an issue.  The collar stands quite high up on my neck and provides very ample protection from rain when wearing a hat.  During light rain situations, I have found that when only wearing a baseball cap (i.e., no rear brim) I did not notice water running down my neck.  On the other hand, when caught in a shower in town without a hat, the collar was not enough protection from moderately blowing rain.  The best solution I have for this is to wear a waterproof hat with a brim which seems to work fine but I have not been able to test this in heavy rain.

The eVENT fabric of the Cruiser Jacket seems to breathe very well.  I have been on a number of hikes in warmer temperatures and have found that although I feel heat building up under the jacket, I do not have excessive problems with perspiration.  A few times I have been in conditions where I feel I am really working up a sweat and found that simply up-zipping the jacket part way allows for adequate ventilation. 

In colder temperatures the fabric tends to get stiff and makes a crinkling sound when I move around.  This does not seem to affect the performance of the jacket with respect to water repellency or breathability.  In windier conditions, I have used the Cruiser Jacket as a wind shell.  I have found it to work well in this capacity.

The pockets on the Cruiser Jacket are located on the side seams and are fairly low down on the garment.  The pockets are of ample size and I can fit my hands in side but I feel that I am reaching far back to get access to the pockets.  The pockets can store gloves, a map, or any variety of small items.  However, when wearing any type of hip belt, I am not able to access the pockets.  I also find that the zipper pulls on the pockets are too small.  I find it difficult to open the pocket zippers quickly, particularly when wearing gloves.   If I wear anything but the thinnest of gloves, I am not able to open the pocket zippers.

The material of the Cruiser Jacket does seem to retain odors.  I have found that over time the jacket has begun to pick up less than favorable smells.  The manufacturer does note that relatively frequent cleaning is necessary to keep the eVENT fabric working properly.  Although the jacket has been picking up odors and worn very often, I have not seen any problems with the water repellency or breathability of the fabric.  I have yet to wash the garment but have rinsed the jacket in only water which has helped in removing some of the odors.  I anticipate washing the garment as part of my long term report.

I typically do not use a stuff sack for my rain gear since I prefer to have it available without any additional fumbling.  Since it is available, I have used the Cruiser Jacket with its stuff sack on hikes where I did not feel that rain was likely but I wanted an additional shell garment.  The jacket stuffs very easily into the sack and the sil-nylon material of the stuff sack slides nicely in and out of a pack.  Most of the time, though, I am not sure what to do with the stuff sack and it ends up staying in one of the jacket’s pockets.

This concludes my Field Report. 

Long Term Report

Report Date: March 8, 2007

Field Information:
Since my Field Report, I have used the Cruiser Jacket on a series of day hikes in central Maryland and northern Virginia.  Temperatures on these hikes ranged from 20 to 50 F (-7 to 16 C).   I only encountered light rain on a few of these hikes but did run into some windy conditions.  Elevations for all these trips ranged from 500-1500 ft (152-457 m)..I continue to wear the jacket around town running errands and to other outdoor activities. 

Product Review:
As I continue to wear the Cruiser Jacket, I like it more and more.  It keeps rain out well and I have found it to be very breathable.  It also seems to be an excellent wind shell.  I have noted that as long as I zip the jacket up I usually stay warm in windy conditions.

As mentioned above, the jacket breathes very well.  I have not found myself wishing for pit-zips or other venting options.  I wore the Cruiser jacket while attending my very first orienteering meet (what a blast – if you haven’t you should try it) where my son decided we should run the course.  I agreed and even though I was overdressed, I was not drenched in sweat at the end of the course which really surprised me.

Since I have not encountered any heavy downpours while wearing the Cruiser Jacket, I tested the product in my home shower.  I put the jacket on over a grey t-shirt so that I would be able to easily see any areas were water may have gotten through.  I wore a waterproof rain hat with a 2.5 in (6 cm) brim to prevent water from running down my neck (I felt this would reasonably replicate what I would wear on the trail).  I subjected the garment to the full force of the shower for a full 5 minutes at which time I dried the jacket off with a towel to prevent water on the outside of the jacket from wetting the shirt underneath.  I found that the jacket did not leak at all.  A small amount of water did manage to get down the front and back of my neck.  The water resistant zipper on the front did not let any water through which was a concern that I had.  After the shower testing, the jacket seemed to dry very quickly at room temperature.  One exception to this was the lycra hem at the bottom and around the wrists.  These areas remained wet much longer than the rest of the garment and felt rather cold and clammy when I put the Loose collar threadsjacket back on.

I next decided that I should launder the jacket and repeat the shower sequence to see if the laundering process affected the product in any way.  Since the jacket has two different washing instructions, I went with the instructions from the manufacturer of the eVENT fabric since they likely know more about the fabric than Integral Designs.  These washing instructions state “Machine wash warm with liquid detergent.  Secure all zippers and closures.  Rinse twice.  Hang dry.  Steam iron warm to rejuvenate water repellent finish.  Do not use bleach or fabric softener.  Do not dry clean.”  These instructions were followed to the letter. I then repeated the shower test in the same manner noted above.  I did not find any water entering the jacket other than around the neck, as before.  I did notice that water did seem to wet the fabric in the area of the shoulders, whereas other areas the water beaded up.  I believe this was due to not ironing this section of the jacket as well as other areas.

The jacket has shown little wear.  I have noticed a small 0.75 in x 0.5 in (1.9 cm x 1.3 cm) patch on the left front shoulder area which has begun to show some wear from pack straps rubbing.  I have found a 1 in (2.5 cm) pull in the fabric on the left sleeve from a run in with a thorn.  I have not noticed any decrease in performance due to these small problems.  I also noted that after laundering the jacket a few of the threads at the base of the collar have loosened up.  This isn’t an opening of the seam but it was noticeable and potentially could be a problem later on.  The photo at the right shows some of the loose threads with simple pin easily inserted under the threads.  I would not have been able to easily do this prior to washing the jacket.

This ends my reporting on the Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket

Summary:
The Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket is a light weight, well constructed rain jacket.  The overall design of the jacket is simple without excess frills but allowing for good fit.  The Cruiser Jacket appears to provide good protection from rain and wind and has excellent breathability.   For the most part, the Cruiser Jacket is simple and performs well, however, the location of the pockets and their zippers makes them hard to access.

Things I like:

    1. Light weight
    2. Good fit
    3. Good water repellency
    4. Good breathability
    5. Snug fit at wrists

Things I don’t like:

    1. Loose threads at Lycra hem (minor issue)
    2. Small zipper pulls on pockets
    3. Not able to access pockets with hip belt
    4. Stiff main zipper
    5. Conflicting washing instructions

I would like to extend my sincere appreciation to Integral Designs and BackpackGearTest.org for the opportunity to test this excellent product.




Read more reviews of Integral Designs gear
Read more gear reviews by Patrick McNeilly

Reviews > Rain Gear > Jackets and Pants > Integral Designs eVENT Cruiser Jacket > Pat McNeilly > Test Report by Patrick McNeilly



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson