BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Sleep Gear > Sleeping Bags > Sierra Designs Cirque and Mist > Jim Hatch > Initial Report

Sierra Designs Cirque down mummy bag (men's regular)
Initial Report

Cique mummy bag

 

Personal Information

  • Name: Jim Hatch
  • Age: 46
  • Height: 5' 9" (1.75 m)
  • Weight: 185 lbs (84 kg) 
  • Sleep type: neutral to cold sleeper
  • Email: colonelcorn76@yahoo.com
  • Location: Connecticut, USA
  • Date : November 5, 2005

PRODUCT INFORMATION 

Manufacturer: Sierra Designs
Manufacturer's website: www.sierradesigns.com
Model: Cirque Men's Regular
Year of manufacture: 2005
Temp Rating: 0F/-18C


According to the manufacturer's website at http://www.sierradesigns.com:

  • Type: Adventure DriZone
  • Insulation: Powerfill 800-Fill Goose Down
  • Trail Weight: 3 lbs 10 oz (1.6 kg)
  • [Measured: 3 lbs 10 oz (1.6 kg)]
  • Fill Weight: 29 oz  (822 g)
  • Inside Length: 80" (2 m)
  • [Measured: 80" (2 m)]
  • [Measured outside length: 86" (2.2 m)]
  • Zipper Side: Left
  • Stuff Size: 10" (25.4 cm)
  • [Measured: 9.5" x 12.5" compressed (24.1 cm x 31.75 cm)]
  • Shell Material: 40D Nylon
  • Liner Material: 40D Polyester
  • Shoulder Girth: 62" (1.57 m)
  • [Measured: 64" (1.63 m)]
  • Hip Girth: 57" (1.45 m)
  • [Measured: 58"  (1.47 m)]
  • Footbox Girth: 43" (1.09 m)
  • [Measured: 44" (1.12 m)]

(* Note: All weights measured on a Pelouze PE5 digital scale, +- 0.1 oz/2.8 g)

Featuring

  • Baffle Construction
  • Compression Stuff Sack
  • Draft Collar
  • DriZone "Waterproof Breathable"
  • Dual Draft Tubes
  • Glow-in-the-Dark Zipper Pulls
  • Pad Locks
  • Snag Free Zipper Tracks
  • MSRP 339.95 USD

PRODUCT DESCRIPTION

The Sierra Designs Cirque sleeping bag is a mummy shaped, winter rated, "outside the tent" bag. Despite its lack of taped seams, its DriZone shell is supposed to be proof against "dew and wind" permitting safe sleeping outside the tent.  It comes with both a compression stuff sack and a cotton "pillowcase" storage bag.

Initial Impression

Opening the box I found the bag shipped in the storage bag (12"/30 cm dia x 14"/35.5 cm tall while in the box). Taking it from the box, I pulled it from the storage bag and found a hang-tag attached to the zipper. It contains similar information as the website (although it states the stuff size is 9" x 19" (23 cm x 48 cm) vs. the website's simple 10"/25.4 cm). Additionally, the tag contains some further information outlining the usefulness of the features noted above. Among the notable claims are some technical info on the DriZone laminated fabric - including the fact that it's a breathable fabric that allows moisture to escape while keeping the rain from coming in. The snag-free zipper tracks are supposed to have been a Sierra Designs innovation ("first in the market") that prevent stuck zippers. It also highlights the draft tube next to the zipper - the Cirque being a 0F (-18C) bag, gets two tubes, top and bottom, and a draft collar for additional warmth. Finally, it states that the bag has baffled construction designed to keep the down from migrating to prevent cold spots. The tag is in both English and French.

So, how does it seem to stack up against these claims? I unrolled it on the floor and fluffed it out. I unzipped the bag and found the compression stuff sack tucked into the foot of the bag. After a quick review, I'm impressed by the pad straps that allow the bag to be attached to a sleeping pad, the included storage bag which I think is a nice touch, and the stuff sack's compression capability. I'm not sure about the usefulness of the glow-in-the-dark zipper pull, and I have a bit of an issue catching some of the inner fabric in the zipper (but it doesn't get stuck, I just zip back down a bit and continue to zip it up). Funny, but the one thing that strikes me as most impressive is the treatment of the Velcro tabs. The bag has a Velcro tab at the top of the zipper and another one inside to bring the ends of the shoulder draft collar together on the left side. Big deal except that Sierra Designs has made the tab long enough to allow it to be folded back on itself where the hook part sticks to a patch of the loop tape. This should keep those fuzzy bits of lint & stuff from embedding themselves in the hook part when the bag is not being used. It's just one of those nice touches that's not obviously necessary but makes so much sense when it's there and makes me think the rest of the bag is as well thought out.

Zipper tab open
Zipper top tab open

Zipper tab folded over
Zipper to tab folded over

Next I flip it over and check out the "pad locks". These are two straps of grosgrain ribbon at 34" and 56" (86 cm and 142 cm) from the foot of the bag. They have small plastic tensioners to allow the straps to be tightened. I slipped my mummy shaped sleeping pad between the bag & straps and tightened them up. Snugged up I flipped it back over, unzipped and climbed inside. Nice and comfortable, fluffy (5.5"/14 cm of loft), smooth, soft material, and toasty warm. I just wanted to take it outside and sleep under the stars.

But, a tester's work is never done, no time for sleeping now. I pulled out my tape measure and scale and got down to business. In addition to the measurements noted above, I checked the footbox height (8"/20 cm) - plenty of room for my size 9 1/2 feet. When loosely (more or less) stuffed in the storage bag which had been 14" (35.5 cm) long in the shipping box, it measured out to a more down-saving 27 1/2" (70 cm) tall. That should keep it from getting compressed in storage, although to tell the truth I tend to store my down bags hanging rather then bagged.

Being an ultralight/low-volume backpacker I was very interested in the size it will take up in my pack. Stuffing it into the stuff sack, it was a 9.5" diameter 17" long (24 x 43 cm) package. Drawing on the compression straps I was able to squeeze it vertically the full length of the straps' adjustability resulting in a 12 1/2" long (32 cm) bundle. Not overly small but pretty good for a cold rated bag like this. (The stuff sack adds 5.7 oz/162 g to the carry weight of the bag.)

Uncompressed stuff sack
Uncompressed Stuff Sack

Compressed stuff sack
Compressed Stuff Sack

Back out of the sack and fluffed back out again, I checked out the construction with a little more care. The hood has the standard drawcord to tighten it around my head. In addition though, it has a nice little down filled baffle tube on the inside of the cord which keeps the cord from pressing into my forehead. Another nice touch. The zipper has a robust draft tube on both the top & the bottom of the zipper. Doesn't look like there's any chance air is leaking through that construction. The shoulder area also has another draft tube that wraps around the top & bottom (chest & back area) with another drawcord inside. The ends of this tube also has a Velcro tab that closes the ends together to further keep the occupant snug. Another series of nice touches.  

Hood area

Draft tubes

Draft tubes, drawcords, and other features

Before I button it back up in preparation for my first trip out, I decide to check out the water resistance of the DriZone shell in the safety of my house. If it's going to leak I want to know that when I'm home, not at 2AM some cold night when the dew or a quick snowstorm wakes me and makes me wish I brought my tent and didn't sleep outside after all. This is especially critical for a down bag. So out comes the hose & sprayer. Sonofagun but it splatters right off! The water that doesn't bounce off, beads on the surface until I shake it off. It puddles in the dips & folds of the bag's loft. I leave it for a couple of hours like that, resting in its water bath. I figure if it doesn't wet out under this treatment I'm willing to risk the elements.

Water beading
Water beading & puddling...no wetting out of the fabric

After two hours of the water treatment, it's still beading up and there is absolutely no wetting of the fabric. I'm okay taking this outside. That means I get to leave 3 lbs (1.4 kg) of tent at home. (I'm going to come up with some small square of Tyvek or something I can suspend over my head for the off-chance snow comes dumping, but my winter pack load appears to have just gotten lighter and smaller.

TESTING

Okay, now for the fun part. Let's get this out into the woods. I'll be starting with an overnight to the Berkshires in Connecticut staying on the state's High Point (Bear Mountain, 2316 ft/706 m -- the nearby Mount Frissell is higher on its southern slope as the state line crosses it but its summit is in Massachusetts). Temperatures have been in the high 20s/low 30s F (-2 to 1 / C) and we've already had snow out there. Subsequent trips will include nights in the Connecticut Appalachian Trail section and several trips into the Berkshires in Massachusetts (elevations to 3491 ft/1064 m). Historically these often come with severe cold, including sub-zero (-18 C) nights. Although I'll try to avoid pushing beyond the bag's rating, I'll likely be coming close. I learned a long time ago that if I'm not wearing every bit of clothing I brought and have been zipped into my bag for a bit, I can't claim to be cold. In severe weather I'll be in silk long underwear, heavy wool pants, shirt, fleece, down sweater and even a down jacket and a hat. That plus this bag should keep me warm in any reasonable weather (once my mustache hairs begin to freeze and break off, I head home).

What I'll be watching for

  • Is it really warm to anything near its temperature rating?

  • Does it shed water/snow in the wild as well as it does in the kitchen?

  • Does it retain its loft after several months in & out of its storage bag and compression sack?

  • Are the glow-in-the-dark zipper pulls really useful or just a marketing gimmick?

  • Do the pad locks (straps) keep me attached to the pad during nighttime thrashing?

  • How well does the snag-free zipper track keep the zipper from snagging or worse, jamming?

  • Do the various draft tubes really keep Mother Nature's frosty breath from my tender parts?

  • Does the baffled construction (6.5"/16.5 cm wide wavy horizontal baffles) hold up under use and keep the down from drifting?

  • Does the DriZone shell really breathe so I don't wake up in a sweaty puddle even if the outside of the bag is dry?

  • Will I see any issues with tears, snags or errant feathers (none are apparent now, the fabric and seams are tight and sturdy, it feels substantial, but will it last)?

Likes/Dislikes So Far

So far I like the bag. It seems nicely constructed and well thought out. The little touches bode well for the quality of the big things. There isn't anything I've come across yet that I don't like with this bag. I hope the feeling lasts.

Cique Sierra Designs logo

I'd like to thank BackpackGearTest and Sierra designs for the opportunity to test this bag.


Backpacking background
I've been backpacking and camping for 30 years (ever since I was a Boy Scout). I'm out once a month for a weekend or more and for 5 nights or more, 2 or 3 times during the year. Most of my backpacking is done in the mountains of the East Coast (Appalachians, Whites, Berkshires, Adirondacks) but I will occasionally camp as far south as the Florida Keys or as far west as the Grand Canyon. Having tired of 60 lb (27 kg) loads, I caught the lightweight bug about 5 years ago and am currently carrying a base pack weight of  less than 10 lbs (4.5 kg) before food and fuel and rarely venture out with more than 20 lbs (9 kg) anymore. I am now trying to develop a low-volume style to go with the lightweight nature of my gear.
 



Read more reviews of Sierra Designs gear
Read more gear reviews by Jim Hatch

Reviews > Sleep Gear > Sleeping Bags > Sierra Designs Cirque and Mist > Jim Hatch > Initial Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson