BackpackGearTest
  Home Guest - Not logged in 
 
 » Register
 » Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
 » Contact

Reviews > Snow Gear > Snowshoes > MSR Lightning Snowshoes > Mike Lipay > Field Report

Field Report - MSR Lightning Snowshoes

by Mike Lipay - March 23, 2006

Description
Date Arrived January 17, 2006 MSR Lightning Snowshoes
Manufacturer Mountain Safety Research (MSR)
Year of Manufacturer 2005
Website http://www.msrcorp.com/
MSRP $249.95 USD
Warranty MSR Snowshoes are guaranteed against defects in materials and workmanship without time limit. Return shipping charges to the consumer for repaired products are covered. Should a product be found defective under this warranty, we will repair it or replace it at our option. (website).
Model 35123
Mfgr. Specs (from website) Dimensions: 8 x 30 in. (20 x 64 cm)
Weight: 3 lbs. 14 oz. 1759 g) per pair
Personal measurements Dimensions: 8 x 30-3/4 in. (20 x 78 cm)
Weight: 3 lbs. 13 oz. (1720 g) per pair



Personal Information
Name Mike Lipay
Age 50
Gender Male
Height 5 ft 8 in / 173 cm
Weight 185 lbs / 83.9 kg
Email hiking AT westernpa DOT us
City, State Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Background I've been hiking and backpacking with the Boy Scouts since the '60s, although currently I hike more solo, with my kids, or as a trail guide for a local outdoor group. I am no ultralight backpacker, my pack (external frame) weighs 29-40 lbs (13-18 kgs) loaded (not including food), though I am always on the look out for ways to cut down on the weight. I'm a low-techie, preferring a hiking staff to trekking poles, compass to GPS, fire to fuel; but I do carry some techie stuff as well, recently switching over to a digital camera from film, and an UV sterilizer from a filter pump.
Additional Bio I have never used snowshoes, though I hike regularly in the winter and the snow my trips have always been in winter boots. The reports submitted will reflect the viewpoint of one just learning to use snowshoes, and as such may be a bit less technical than one who is more experienced.



Field Usage
Date of Test Jan. 21, 2006
Length of Trip 1 day
Weather 42°F (5.5°C) snowing, cloudy, 6-8in base (15-20cm)
Location Boyce Park, Allegheny County, Pa.
Field Test This was an introductory hike to get acquainted with attaching the MSR Lightning Snowshoes, walking in them, and removing them. Attaching is proving to be the most difficult part of the entire experience. I find the straps difficult to attach with gloved hands, especially the top straps which go over the upper portion of my boot. Pulling them tight and getting the pin into the hole in the strap is not easy to do. It takes several attempts to get the straps in place, and fed through the holding clip. Once in place they do an excellent job of holding the boot to the showshoe and have never come loose.

Walking in the MSR Lightning Snowshoes is remarkably easy to learn, and little different from walking on bare ground without showshoes. It really is as easy as putting one foot in front of the other; of course, you need to remember to keep you feet a little further apart than usual. I do find myself forgetting to keep my feet apart, which usually ends up with the rear of one snowshoe on top of the front of the other -- not a pretty sight when I try to move the lower foot. Removing the snowshoes is a lot easier, just stretching the strap off of the pins and lifting the foot.

This hike was a short 4-mile (6.4 km) hike on fairly level ground (rolling hills), with elevation changes of no more than 150 ft (46 m). While walking in the MSR Lightning Snowshoes is easy, walking in snow is a real workout. After completing the first 2 miles (3.2 km) I felt as though I had walked twice as far, I was glad I had picked a short trail when I did the returning 2 miles (3.2 km).

Date of Test Jan. 28, 2006
Length of Trip 2 days
Weather 28°F (-2°C), snowing, cloudy, winds at 15-22 mph
(24-35 kph), 6-8 in base (15.2 - 20.3 cm)
Location Laurel Highland Trail, Laurel Hill Section, Pa.
Field Test This section of the Laurel Highland Trail (LHT) is fairly level, with elevation changes not exceeding 200 ft (61 m), and 8 miles (12.8 km) each way. The trail tends to be narrow as it works it's way around trees, rocks, and cliffs. Switchbacks are plentyful, and the trail rarely gets more than 4 ft (1.2 m) wide - this last part provided challenges for the MSR Lightning snowshoes, which I will get into later).

I'm still having problems attaching my boots to the snowshoes. I find it difficult to get the holes in the straps to go into the pins while I am wearing gloves. Removing the gloves definately makes the task easier, but with windchills in the 11-13°F (-10.5 - -11.7 °C) range, removing gloves is the last thing I wanted to do. The right boot remains a problem, even though I have adjusted the strap to provide the longest possible amount of strap; for some reason this one seems too short for the task. I do have to admit that the rubber straps have remained plyable even in these cold temps -- I had thought they would tighten up when the temperatures dropped.

The narrow trails, and frequent swithcbacks, have proven to be a problem with the length of the MSR Lightning snowshoes. I don't always have enough width to keep my feet as far apart as they need to be to prevent one from going on top of the other. What I have wound up doing is taking longer steps to make sure on foot is clearly in front of the other. This is not natural and takes a great deal of effort.

The other issue has been with the switchbacks. Turning in the snowshoes is not an easy task, I find I must inch into it, shuffling my feet a little at a time, until I have made the turn and can resume walking straight. This takes time and, on a trail such as this one, definately lengthens the time it takes to get to where I am going.

I have found one distinct advantage to the MSR Lightnings: sinking into the snow doesn't happen! I took a break around mid-day, had to remove the snowshoes so that I could sit on a boulder and enjoy lunch. I had put my pack down a little further than I could reach so I slid down the boulder, figuring on walking the few steps to the pack. WOW! I sunk into 12 in (30.5 cm) of snow! Looking back at my tracks I had only sunk about 1-2 in (2.5 - 5.0 cm)! What an odd feeling.

After lunch I walked about 1/2 mile (0.8 km) further to a clearing which held a view of the valley below. Out of curiosity I stuck my 6 ft (1.8 m) hiking staff into the snow -- amazingly it sunk about halfway into the snow before hitting ground -- I was still only sinking a 1-2 in (2.5 - 5.0 cm). Weird!

Date of Test Feb. 18, 2006
Length of Trip 2 days
Weather 22°F - 35°F (-5.6°C - 1.7°C) snowing, cloudy, 18-52 in base (38-132 cm)
Location Seven Springs Ski Resort, Pa.
Field Test For this hike I took advantage of a local ski resort, with abundant cross-country ski trails, to try the MSR Lightning snowshoes in some seriously deep snow (at least for this area). The solid base here was 18-26 in (38-66 cm), with man-made snow making up the remainder. I also had the opportunity to go out with a group of other, more experienced, snowshoers (is that a word?), and get tips on usage as well as comparing the MSR Lightnings to other brands/styles.

Getting a chance to see other lashing systems, the MSR's straps are nowhere near as easy. One person had a hook-and-loop system that attached to his boots in a few seconds, with gloved hands and little effort. Within the group I was the only person who had to remove their gloves to securely fasten the snowshoes. The MSR Lightnings are also longer than the tubular aluminum snowshoes of my companions, a good 4-6 in (10-15 cm) longer than anyone elses.

The trails here are wide, wide enough for cross-country skiing, and for the occasional horse-drawn sled that passed us by. By now I was no longer stepping on my own snowshoes, a skill that I now relish; and a skill that helped me move quickly to the side when those employing faster transportation methods came by. By the end of the trip I had learned to side-step to get off of the trail, rather than trying to turn and walk to the side. This was a skill taught to me by others in the group; basically picking up your left foot and moving it sideways half a step, then following with the right foot, and repeating until I got off of the trail. This is a lot faster than trying to walk to the side - and speed is necessary with a horse and sled coming towards me.

I have noticed two distinct advantages to the MSR Lightnings over my companions snowshoes:

  1. The Lightning's longer design kept me from sinking into the snow as far as others - this was especially true when we hit the man-made snow. I was not sinking more than 3 in (7.6 cm), while others were going as much as 5-6 in (12.7-15.2 cm) in the powdery snow.

  2. We had to cross a frozen stream at one point, the teeth on the MSR Lightnings bit into the ice and gave me far superior traction. I noticed that the tublular shoes only had "teeth" up in the toe area, which only bit into the ice when the toe came forward. My companions were forced to do more of an ice-skating style, where their toes tipped up to bite in while they slid their other foot forward. I was safely across the ice in a fraction of the time.

Personal Observations
  • Walking in the MSR Lightning Showshoes is almost as natural as walking, just have to remember to keep my feet a little wider apart
  • Turning on tight trails is tricky, practicing a shuffle-turn ahead of time is helpful
  • The straps could be a few knotches longer, I'm having problems getting a good grip on them with gloves on
  • The pins should be bent outward just a tad more, I find it difficult to catch the hole in the strap onto the pin
  • The MSR Lightning Snowshoes have much better traction on ice than the others I have observed
Future Plans Pray for more snow. The weather has started to take a turn for the worse (relatively speaking), and most of the snow in the area has melted prematurely.

I would like to sincerely thank MSR and BGT for giving me the opportunity to test the Lightning Showshoes, it has been a real eye-opener into the world of snowshoeing.



Read more reviews of MSR gear
Read more gear reviews by Mike Lipay

Reviews > Snow Gear > Snowshoes > MSR Lightning Snowshoes > Mike Lipay > Field Report



All material on this site is the exclusive property of BackpackGearTest.org.
BackpackGearTest software copyright David Anderson