![]() |
| Home | Guest - Not logged in | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
» Register
» Login
Gear Reviews
Documents
Tools
» Contact
|
Reviews > Trekking Poles > Poles > MSR OverLand Carbon > Shane Bryan > Long Term ReportLong Term Report - MSR OverLand
Carbon
Trekking Poles
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Manufacturer: | Mountain Safety Research (MSR) |
| Year made: | 2004 |
| WebSite: | http://www.msrcorp.com/ |
| Listed weight: | 17 oz (482 g) per pair |
| Actual
weight: |
16.8 oz
(476 g) per pair (8.4 oz / 238 g ea.) |
| Listed
Lengths: |
25.6 - 55
in (65 - 140 cm) |
| Actual
Lengths: |
26.25 -
56.75 in (67 - 144 cm), measured from end to end. |
| MSRP: |
$129.95 USD |
| Product description: |
At eight ounces apiece, these lightweight poles are at home on the trail as part of an ultralight hiker’s bag of tricks.
|
| |
Three Sisters Loop:
On hike I covered 50 mi (81 km) in a
loop
around the "Three Sisters", also known and North, Middle and South
Sisters. Our party started on September 3rd and finished 4 days
later on the 6th. Altitude ranged from 5200 ft (1585 m) to 7100
ft (2164 m). It had been raining and snowing all the previous day
and night before departure. The morning of the first day was
foggy but no active precipitation. There would be no rain or snow
for the remainder of the trek. Below is a brief synopsis of the
daily conditions and experiences using these trekking poles.
Day
1: 12 mi (19.3 km) from Lava Camp to Soap Creek. Today's
trail started at 5300 ft (1615 m) following wooded Lodgepole pine
forest tails,
rising to 6100 ft (1859 m) after 3 mi (4.8 km), dropping again to
5300 ft (1615 m) at 4.75
mi (7.7 km), peaking again to 6300 ft (1920 m) at 9.5 mi (15.3 km),
descending to our evening
camp (Soap Creek) at 5700 ft (1737 m). Brief portions of the
trail would
have been dusty and dry if not for the previous days rain. The
poles were used on one off trail excursion to get a shot of North
Sister from between the trees were I relied heavily on the poles to
keep from slipping down the steep slope. There were two,
non-technical, stream crossings where the poles were used to aid in
balancing while traversing the log bridge.
Day 2: 12 mi (19.3 km) from Soap Creek to stealth camp west of Moraine Lake. Continuing from camp last night at 5700 ft (1737 m), ascending to Green Lakes pass, 7050 ft (2149 m), at 5.5 mi (8.9 km), descending to 6000 ft (1829 m) at 9.6 mi (15.5 km), ending the day at 6700 ft (2042 m). Today's trail variously traversed Lodgepole pine forests with packed earthen trails, ghostly white forests of long past fires, crossing vast tendrils of pumice sand "flows" breaking up the north eastern slopes of South Sister, and finally ending in the wide fields of volcanic debris and gravel, crunching under every foot fall and strike of the poles. I quickly learn that to maintain my sanity, I must block out the incessant clatter of the carbide tips on every step. The approach to Green Lakes pass was very rocky and narrow, creating the opportunity to learn to pay attention to pole placement. Due to chronic knee problems, I was very thankful to have the poles along on this section. I also used the poles to lift one side of my hammock tarp to improve my view in the morning.
Day 3: 13 mi (20.9 km) from west of Moraine Lake to stealth
camp south of Obsidian Falls restricted area. This morning we
started the day's hike at the highest elevation for the day, but our
hike brought us through 6 ascents and 7 descents, the steepest of which
was 800 ft (244 m) in 1 mi (1.61 km). Our trail stared out in
volcanic gravel,
sand and dust for the first 3.5 mi (5.6 km), mostly through the Wickiup
Plains. Eventually, we descended into the soft and welcome shade
of the conifer forests of the western slopes of South Sister where the
trail was packed earth. We crossed several Lupine and Bear grass
covered meadows, some with extremely rutted trails that prevented
proper pole usage. In these locations, I tucked the poles behind
my arms, tips pointed vertically up until the trail conditions
improved. At our morning breakfast stop, I used the poles to
pitch my tarp in the sun to dry it off from the overnight condensation
and morning dew.
Day
4: 11.5 mi (18.5 km) from south of Obsidian Falls, returning to
trail head at Lava Camp. Today was by far the hardest and most
difficult trail conditions of the whole hike. This was not the
day of greatest elevation change, that was yesterday, but today was
almost entirely spent traversing and climbing through volcanic
flows. The trail was narrow and the rocks sharp. Our morning
started from our camp elevation of 6550 ft (1996 m), dropping only 400
ft (122 m) in 3
mi (4.8 km). The trail then ascended up to Opie Dilldock pass
at 7000
ft (2134 m). The approach to Opie Dilldock pass is a 13% grade
with many
switchbacks through a very steep walled ravine. Once this hurdle
was conquered, our next challenge was Yapoah Crater, only a 5% grade
with no switchbacks, but on very loose volcanic sand. One step
forward, two steps back kind of conditions. This was followed by
another mile of dense, narrow volcanic rock strewn trail, eventually
leading back into the final 3 mi (4.8 km) push through the dusty, wide
Lodgepole pine forest trail to the trail head. The trail
conditions on this day resulted in a fair amount of scaring on the soft
rubber baskets and on the lower segment of the telescoping poles, but
there was no visible damage to the carbide tips. I found this
quite impressive given the kind of conditions they were subjected to.
Day hikes and around the
neighborhood use: I have since used the poles while hiking
on flat established trails and neighborhood parks. I have also
pitched tarps using the poles in a variety of configurations. I
have used the poles as the primary ridge line supports for a tarp
pitched
for ground sleeping, and as side lifters for my tarp pitched over my
hammocks, allowing for unobstructed views. I have allowed my
children to try the poles as well, confirming that their adjustibility
and weight meet the requirements of a wide range of uses and needs.
Here is an update on specific features of the MSR Overland Carbon Fiber Trekking Poles since my Field report.
On
the pommel of each hand grip, there is a pin or dowel that secures
the top of the handle to the shaft of the handle, presumably removable
for servicing or replacing the wrist strap. On my set of poles,
one of these "pins" very slightly protruded. This protrusion
was initially only about 1/16th of an inch (1.5 mm), and only bothered
me when held in such a way as to be against my thumb. It bothered
me enough to try to do something about it, but I
could only get it to move in one direction, the WRONG direction!
As you can see from the photographs here, it now extends about 3/16th
of an inch (4.8 mm), rendering it extremely irritating in any
position. I have tried in vain to get the pin to go back into
proper position, but every attempt only causes the plastic to deform
and
scar.
I
suspect the initial protrusion in my poles was a quality defect in
manufacturing not caught prior to distribution and I would hope it is
not a general condition of all their poles. I do not have any
other MSR Overland Carbon Fiber Trekking Poles to compare to, and none
are available at any local outfitters.| Name: | Shane Bryan |
| Age: | 35 |
| Gender: | Male |
| Height: | 5 ft, 10 in (1.78 m) |
| Weight: | 175 lbs (79 kg) |
| Email Address: | mirage(AT)peak(dot)org |
| WebSite: |
http://www.peak.org/~webdawg |
| Address: | Corvallis, Oregon, USA |
| Date: |
December 23, 2004 |
| Backpacking Background: | I grew up hiking short trips in the Catskills and Adirondacks with Boy Scouts and friends. In college I spent a little over a week in the Adirondacks with a LaVida outdoor experience. Most of the hiking I have done was on weekend or over nights with external frame packs. I spent some time on the Saranac lakes as well. Now I do my hiking on the Oregon Coast and Cascade ranges, usually late spring - fall. The fall of 2003 began my introduction to light/ultralight gear for the first time. I hope to begin section hiking the PCT this year. |
| |